The Teeth in the Mud Room | Into the Paranormal

In the early 1970s, a family moved into what seemed like the perfect suburban home just outside of Boston. But what starts as an innocent curiosity quickly becomes a lifelong mystery filled with strange noises, moving objects, and phantom figures. The narrator, just a child at the time, experiences unexplained events—footsteps in the attic, lamps turning on by themselves, and strange electronic malfunctions that defy logic. The most unsettling discovery? Two human teeth, found a year apart, in the exact same place in the basement Mud Room.

As the family confronts these bizarre incidents, they uncover strange local history—a massive fire, old artifacts buried nearby, and hints of a past that refuses to stay buried. While the father believes the presence feeds on fear, the narrator can’t help but wonder if they were dealing with more than just poltergeist activity. What happens when the things that haunt us refuse to leave? And what do you do when the unexplained follows you, waiting for the next moment to strike?