INTRO: Welcome to the NSPCC Learning Podcast, where
INTRO: we share learning and expertise in child protection
INTRO: from inside and outside of the organisation.
INTRO: We aim to create debate, encourage reflection
INTRO: and share good practice on how we can all work
INTRO: together to keep babies, children and young
INTRO: people safe.
PRODUCER: Welcome to the NSPCC learning Podcast.
PRODUCER: In this episode, you'll hear a discussion
PRODUCER: between a panel of experts from the Social
PRODUCER: Workers with Deaf Children and Professionals
PRODUCER: Working Group.
PRODUCER: This discussion, recorded in October 2023,
PRODUCER: explores how the differing language and
PRODUCER: communication needs of d/Deaf children can
PRODUCER: affect their safety and the child protection
PRODUCER: support they receive.
PRODUCER: Shirley Wilson, senior development consultant at
PRODUCER: the NSPCC, chaired the panel.
SHIRLEY WILSON: I'm Shirley Wilson.
SHIRLEY WILSON: I've been working as a senior consultant
SHIRLEY WILSON: for the NSPCC now for 12
SHIRLEY WILSON: years in a specific role in relation
SHIRLEY WILSON: to d/Deaf and disabled children and young
SHIRLEY WILSON: people.
SHIRLEY WILSON: What that actually means is I'm
SHIRLEY WILSON: responsible for working with a range of
SHIRLEY WILSON: external organisations to support
SHIRLEY WILSON: their safeguarding arrangements.
SHIRLEY WILSON: And that includes things like bespoke
SHIRLEY WILSON: training, reviewing their child
SHIRLEY WILSON: protection/safeguarding policies and
SHIRLEY WILSON: procedures. And prior to the NSPCC, I
SHIRLEY WILSON: worked as a social worker and manager in a
SHIRLEY WILSON: number of local authorities.
SHIRLEY WILSON: So now I'm going to introduce our topic
SHIRLEY WILSON: for today.
SHIRLEY WILSON: The headline of this is we're going to be
SHIRLEY WILSON: talking about language and communication
SHIRLEY WILSON: in relation to safeguarding d/Deaf
SHIRLEY WILSON: children and young people.
SHIRLEY WILSON: And that links to their families, because
SHIRLEY WILSON: one of the things that we do know about is
SHIRLEY WILSON: that language and communication
SHIRLEY WILSON: barriers faced by d/Deaf children, young
SHIRLEY WILSON: people actually manifests itself
SHIRLEY WILSON: in a way that increases safeguarding
SHIRLEY WILSON: risk. And I want to explore that today.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Just briefly, I just want to say what the
SHIRLEY WILSON: social workers with d/Deaf children and
SHIRLEY WILSON: professionals is. It's actually an
SHIRLEY WILSON: external group of social workers and
SHIRLEY WILSON: allied professionals who are working in a
SHIRLEY WILSON: range of domains.
SHIRLEY WILSON: These include local authorities, academia,
SHIRLEY WILSON: mental health, research and the charities
SHIRLEY WILSON: sector, in relation to d/Deaf
SHIRLEY WILSON: children and their families across
SHIRLEY WILSON: England. We've been chairing this group
SHIRLEY WILSON: for a long time, and all of you are
SHIRLEY WILSON: longstanding members of the group.
SHIRLEY WILSON: But what I want to make reference to is
SHIRLEY WILSON: that we produced some guidance —
SHIRLEY WILSON: and I particularly want to highlight a
SHIRLEY WILSON: thanks to Chris
SHIRLEY WILSON: Mullen from the NDCS, who's no longer
SHIRLEY WILSON: working for them anymore, he's moved on to
SHIRLEY WILSON: other careers — but he spent a lot of time
SHIRLEY WILSON: preparing the guidance, called 'Guidance
SHIRLEY WILSON: for Safeguarding Partners in England:
SHIRLEY WILSON: d/Deaf Children, Young People and their
SHIRLEY WILSON: Families', which we put together over
SHIRLEY WILSON: quite a long period of time
SHIRLEY WILSON: as a big collaboration.
SHIRLEY WILSON: And that finally went on the website at
SHIRLEY WILSON: the NDCS in August 2022.
SHIRLEY WILSON: The guidance is actually supporting
SHIRLEY WILSON: safeguarding partners and their
SHIRLEY WILSON: partnership boards in England to
SHIRLEY WILSON: consider what the safeguarding needs
SHIRLEY WILSON: of d/Deaf children, young people and their
SHIRLEY WILSON: families are with regard to the services
SHIRLEY WILSON: they provide. Now that sounds quite
SHIRLEY WILSON: long-winded, and I think what we can
SHIRLEY WILSON: do now is do much more
SHIRLEY WILSON: of a relaxed discussion about what we're
SHIRLEY WILSON: looking at, and I've got a number of
SHIRLEY WILSON: questions that I'm going to bring into the
SHIRLEY WILSON: discussion. But first of all, I'd like
SHIRLEY WILSON: people to introduce themselves. So can I
SHIRLEY WILSON: start with Professor Alys Young, then
SHIRLEY WILSON: we'll do Jo, and then Tim, thank you very
SHIRLEY WILSON: much.
ALYS YOUNG: Thanks, Shirley. Hello everybody.
ALYS YOUNG: I my name is Alys Young and I've worked for
ALYS YOUNG: many, many years alongside d/Deaf colleagues
ALYS YOUNG: in social work and in research.
ALYS YOUNG: I'm professor of social work at the University
ALYS YOUNG: of Manchester, and I'm also the co-director
ALYS YOUNG: of the SORD Research Group.
ALYS YOUNG: SORD, which is social research with
ALYS YOUNG: deaf people.
JO HORNSBY: Hello, everyone, I'm Jo Hornsby.
JO HORNSBY: I'm a social worker and have been a specialist
JO HORNSBY: social worker working with d/Deaf children and
JO HORNSBY: young people for quite a few years
JO HORNSBY: now. I work for the local authority
JO HORNSBY: in Suffolk.
JO HORNSBY: I used to be part of a specialist service,
JO HORNSBY: which I feel very privileged to have been
JO HORNSBY: working during that time when there were
JO HORNSBY: specialist services.
JO HORNSBY: In more recent years.
JO HORNSBY: I've remained a specialist worker but within
JO HORNSBY: the disabled children and young people's team
JO HORNSBY: in children and young people's service in
JO HORNSBY: Suffolk.
TIM RICHARDSON: My name is Tim Richardson.
TIM RICHARDSON: I worked in national d/Deaf CAMHS, child
TIM RICHARDSON: and adolescent mental health services, from
TIM RICHARDSON: 2010.
TIM RICHARDSON: I was the manager of the northern arm of
TIM RICHARDSON: National d/Deaf CAMHS, but I was also
TIM RICHARDSON: part of the leading group for the national
TIM RICHARDSON: development of national d/Deaf CAMHS
TIM RICHARDSON: alongside people like Professor Barry
TIM RICHARDSON: Wright and Doctor Sophie Roberts.
SHIRLEY WILSON: So I'm going to kick off with the first
SHIRLEY WILSON: question.
SHIRLEY WILSON: I might initially ask Alys to do an
SHIRLEY WILSON: initial response and then let's all chip
SHIRLEY WILSON: in.
SHIRLEY WILSON: The first question is about what
SHIRLEY WILSON: the additional support that a d/Deaf
SHIRLEY WILSON: child might need in relation to reporting
SHIRLEY WILSON: abuse or making
SHIRLEY WILSON: a disclosure. So what I'm looking at here
SHIRLEY WILSON: is what might that look like and how do
SHIRLEY WILSON: you think they could receive this type of
SHIRLEY WILSON: support or how could this support be
SHIRLEY WILSON: developed. So I'll kick off with you
SHIRLEY WILSON: Alys, and then everybody else can chip in.
ALYS YOUNG: So it's a really, really important question.
ALYS YOUNG: But before I get to it, I just want to go one
ALYS YOUNG: step back, which is just to remind
ALYS YOUNG: people who are viewing this podcast
ALYS YOUNG: that we're talking about d/Deaf children now
ALYS YOUNG: at this point in the 21st century.
ALYS YOUNG: And that's really important because d/Deaf
ALYS YOUNG: children now and the conditions in which
ALYS YOUNG: they're growing up and what's available
ALYS YOUNG: for d/Deaf children and their families is very
ALYS YOUNG: different than 20 years ago or 30 years ago.
ALYS YOUNG: And that's quite an important point, because
ALYS YOUNG: some experienced professionals might have an
ALYS YOUNG: image in their mind about d/Deaf children's
ALYS YOUNG: capabilities or the barriers that d/Deaf
ALYS YOUNG: children face that was actually formed in
ALYS YOUNG: previous time rather than contemporary time.
ALYS YOUNG: So something that we're all going to be
ALYS YOUNG: talking about is deaf children now, not deaf
ALYS YOUNG: children in the past. That links really
ALYS YOUNG: for me to another point.
ALYS YOUNG: D/deaf children at this point in the 21st
ALYS YOUNG: century generally are identified
ALYS YOUNG: very early. So that means their d/Deafness is
ALYS YOUNG: recognised very early on in life, from
ALYS YOUNG: baby onwards.
ALYS YOUNG: And we have very sophisticated hearing
ALYS YOUNG: technologies that are available for d/Deaf
ALYS YOUNG: children now, whether they're hearing aids,
ALYS YOUNG: whether they're cochlear implants.
ALYS YOUNG: We've also got a society that's very welcoming
ALYS YOUNG: of sign language.
ALYS YOUNG: You're seeing sign language everywhere,
ALYS YOUNG: whether it's Strictly Come Dancing or Bake-Off
ALYS YOUNG: or, you know, it's just in the aether in
ALYS YOUNG: society. So some of the stigma around
ALYS YOUNG: that perhaps is dissipating a little bit.
ALYS YOUNG: And we've got the new BSL Act
ALYS YOUNG: that came in at the end of last year, which
ALYS YOUNG: formally recognises the legal status of sign
ALYS YOUNG: language. What I'm saying here is
ALYS YOUNG: there's a sort of assumption growing in my
ALYS YOUNG: view, that the conditions are right
ALYS YOUNG: for d/Deaf children really to be a bit like
ALYS YOUNG: hearing children.
ALYS YOUNG: There's a sense out there that really
ALYS YOUNG: there aren't that many difficulties here,
ALYS YOUNG: there aren't that many barriers, but the truth
ALYS YOUNG: is completely the opposite.
ALYS YOUNG: To give you some examples; if you are
ALYS YOUNG: a hearing professional or just a hearing
ALYS YOUNG: person who's not used to being
ALYS YOUNG: around d/Deaf people, either professionally or
ALYS YOUNG: socially, if you hear a child speak
ALYS YOUNG: well — with hearing aids, for example — you
ALYS YOUNG: might think that they understand well.
ALYS YOUNG: Actually, that's not true.
ALYS YOUNG: If you see a child who signs,
ALYS YOUNG: you might think that they read well.
ALYS YOUNG: That's not necessarily true.
ALYS YOUNG: That very fundamental difference between
ALYS YOUNG: expressive communication and receptive
ALYS YOUNG: communication, so how well you seem to be able
ALYS YOUNG: to communicate and how well you can
ALYS YOUNG: understand; these are very often not
ALYS YOUNG: equivalent for children and professionals
ALYS YOUNG: very frequently misinterpret that.
ALYS YOUNG: And so for me, the first barrier I'd like to
ALYS YOUNG: suggest around reporting is
ALYS YOUNG: the assumptions that adults make
ALYS YOUNG: about d/Deaf children's capabilities around
ALYS YOUNG: communication.
ALYS YOUNG: And very often in a situation where a child
ALYS YOUNG: might be wishing to report something terrible
ALYS YOUNG: that's been happening to them, their preferred
ALYS YOUNG: language is perhaps not recognised, or
ALYS YOUNG: their preferred way to interact is perhaps
ALYS YOUNG: not recognised because, after all, it's easier
ALYS YOUNG: just to think, "oh, a deaf child can speak,
ALYS YOUNG: it's fine, we'll just use spoken language." So
ALYS YOUNG: my first point is: what is the child's
ALYS YOUNG: preference and how do we understand that
ALYS YOUNG: and how do we meet that.
ALYS YOUNG: And if a child doesn't see that happening for
ALYS YOUNG: them then that's a major barrier to reporting.
ALYS YOUNG: But I wonder whether, Joanne, from your
ALYS YOUNG: practice, that's something that you would
ALYS YOUNG: agree with? Or have you seen a different point
ALYS YOUNG: of view?
JO HORNSBY: Yeah. No, completely.
JO HORNSBY: I mean, I think the key is absolutely to
JO HORNSBY: start with where that child is at and
JO HORNSBY: that child-centred approach
JO HORNSBY: and understanding the preferences of that
JO HORNSBY: child and really understanding how
JO HORNSBY: they are communicating and what their
JO HORNSBY: experiences are on a day-to-day basis.
JO HORNSBY: And that's where it's so important that there
JO HORNSBY: are professionals involved and around that
JO HORNSBY: child at that time
JO HORNSBY: to have that awareness, so that
JO HORNSBY: they can really understand what's going on for
JO HORNSBY: that child and to be able to communicate
JO HORNSBY: with that child and reach
JO HORNSBY: those issues that the child may be
JO HORNSBY: experiencing.
JO HORNSBY: And that's where perhaps we've seen
JO HORNSBY: a bit of a change
JO HORNSBY: over the past few years in that
JO HORNSBY: those specialist teams aren't there in the
JO HORNSBY: same way that they were.
JO HORNSBY: And there might be specialist workers, but it
JO HORNSBY: might be more difficult for that child
JO HORNSBY: to gain access to those.
JO HORNSBY: So, yes, it's very
JO HORNSBY: tricky. And of course, you know, it's also
JO HORNSBY: very important to be...
JO HORNSBY: I think when we often become involved,
JO HORNSBY: it's where families are really struggling.
JO HORNSBY: So it's also being able to
JO HORNSBY: understand where the parents are at and
JO HORNSBY: what experiences that parents have
JO HORNSBY: had. Obviously, as we know, most
JO HORNSBY: d/Deaf children are born to hearing parents.
JO HORNSBY: So we're, often working with
JO HORNSBY: people who may have had very limited,
JO HORNSBY: knowledge or experience of being
JO HORNSBY: around d/Deaf people in their
JO HORNSBY: lives, so this can be a real shock
JO HORNSBY: to them.
JO HORNSBY: And again, it's really
JO HORNSBY: important for those families to have access to
JO HORNSBY: workers who have got that awareness and
JO HORNSBY: understanding about what that family might be
JO HORNSBY: going through at that time.
SHIRLEY WILSON: That's great. Tim, have you got some
SHIRLEY WILSON: thoughts on this?
TIM RICHARDSON: Yes, thanks Shirley.
TIM RICHARDSON: I think at the risk of labouring the
TIM RICHARDSON: point, quite often d/Deaf children
TIM RICHARDSON: and young people will communicate in the
TIM RICHARDSON: way that the people around them can best
TIM RICHARDSON: receive. So they will modify their
TIM RICHARDSON: communication to meet the needs of those
TIM RICHARDSON: around them. I think going back to Alys'
TIM RICHARDSON: point, it's really key that before we even
TIM RICHARDSON: start out, don't make those assumptions.
TIM RICHARDSON: Don't be seduced by how well a
TIM RICHARDSON: young person might be communicating to
TIM RICHARDSON: think that that is their preferred way of
TIM RICHARDSON: communicating.
TIM RICHARDSON: It takes a little bit of effort,
TIM RICHARDSON: and what we would call something like
TIM RICHARDSON: scaffolding, not to take that face value
TIM RICHARDSON: thing, but to go back a step.
TIM RICHARDSON: For example, when you're talking about
TIM RICHARDSON: emotions, you might want to first talk
TIM RICHARDSON: about what an emotion is and have a real
TIM RICHARDSON: understanding that the young person
TIM RICHARDSON: understands what you're talking about
TIM RICHARDSON: before you then launch into what emotions
TIM RICHARDSON: a young person might be feeling.
TIM RICHARDSON: Key, I think, is having
TIM RICHARDSON: people who understand the d/Deaf
TIM RICHARDSON: experience and whether that be
TIM RICHARDSON: a deaf person is great,
TIM RICHARDSON: or a sign language interpreter; people
TIM RICHARDSON: who are going to be keyed in
TIM RICHARDSON: or more linked in with the language
TIM RICHARDSON: and the communication and to be able to
TIM RICHARDSON: pick up on those subtleties that, if
TIM RICHARDSON: you're not used to working with d/Deaf
TIM RICHARDSON: children and young people, you could very
TIM RICHARDSON: well miss out on.
ALYS YOUNG: Could I possibly just add to what you're
ALYS YOUNG: saying about emotion, Tim?
ALYS YOUNG: Because I think it's absolutely crucial here.
ALYS YOUNG: I think that, linked again to barriers
ALYS YOUNG: to reporting or barriers to abuse being
ALYS YOUNG: recognised by other people — because obviously
ALYS YOUNG: it's both things. It's a child reporting or in
ALYS YOUNG: some cases it might be an adult recognising
ALYS YOUNG: there's something wrong. So my point refers to
ALYS YOUNG: both. One of the things about d/Deafness,
ALYS YOUNG: whether you're a spoken language user or a
ALYS YOUNG: sign language user, is that there is an
ALYS YOUNG: interruption in some way to your ability to
ALYS YOUNG: pick up language, ideas,
ALYS YOUNG: general conversation,
ALYS YOUNG: kind of world knowledge, and d/Deaf children
ALYS YOUNG: in different ways experience
ALYS YOUNG: a lack in that. Some are superb, absolutely;
ALYS YOUNG: almost no filter, no difference.
ALYS YOUNG: But for many children there are significant
ALYS YOUNG: difficulties in learning
ALYS YOUNG: about nuances.
ALYS YOUNG: So, years ago, I remember a very well known,
ALYS YOUNG: professional working in this area used to talk
ALYS YOUNG: about emotionally toned language
ALYS YOUNG: so that if you are actually in conversations
ALYS YOUNG: all the time, you can pick up quite easily the
ALYS YOUNG: difference between being furious, being mildly
ALYS YOUNG: angry, being a little annoyed.
ALYS YOUNG: You pick up those differences in language, and
ALYS YOUNG: you develop inside the emotional toning
ALYS YOUNG: of your own understanding of the world.
ALYS YOUNG: I think for d/Deaf children, that's really
ALYS YOUNG: difficult to do if there are blocks in
ALYS YOUNG: access just to casual communication,
ALYS YOUNG: never mind anything else.
ALYS YOUNG: So then taking your point Tim, when you come
ALYS YOUNG: to a situation where a child might
ALYS YOUNG: have experienced abuse and you're asking
ALYS YOUNG: a question that's about emotion and about
ALYS YOUNG: understanding the world emotionally and
ALYS YOUNG: psychologically, that child might not
ALYS YOUNG: have the expected range of understanding
ALYS YOUNG: of a child of that age.
ALYS YOUNG: Or they might do. Again, we can't make
ALYS YOUNG: assumptions generally; every child is
ALYS YOUNG: different. But I think it is a really key
ALYS YOUNG: point that professionals who aren't
ALYS YOUNG: specialists, like Joanne was talking about,
ALYS YOUNG: are unlikely to realise is significant.
TIM RICHARDSON: I think that's absolutely spots on Alys,
TIM RICHARDSON: and I think it goes back to that asking
TIM RICHARDSON: the question behind that might feel a
TIM RICHARDSON: little bit obvious.
TIM RICHARDSON: But when you ask...
TIM RICHARDSON: Quite often we speak with young people...
TIM RICHARDSON: And this to contextualise it, the young
TIM RICHARDSON: people we work with have significant
TIM RICHARDSON: mental health issues. So we're talking
TIM RICHARDSON: about a particular population within a
TIM RICHARDSON: population. But very often it's not
TIM RICHARDSON: infrequent where the three emotions they
TIM RICHARDSON: can name are happy, angry and sad.
TIM RICHARDSON: So there's no nuance, going back to the
TIM RICHARDSON: toning.
TIM RICHARDSON: That also gets played out in behaviour.
TIM RICHARDSON: So you can go from a young person sitting
TIM RICHARDSON: there in the classroom to a young person
TIM RICHARDSON: acting out very aggressively and people
TIM RICHARDSON: around them being genuinely surprised
TIM RICHARDSON: about where that came from.
TIM RICHARDSON: But it almost mirrors their understanding
TIM RICHARDSON: of, because there was no language, there
TIM RICHARDSON: was no way to express "I'm starting to
TIM RICHARDSON: feel frustrated now."
SHIRLEY WILSON: Can I just add to this a slightly
SHIRLEY WILSON: different perspective, and then I'll move
SHIRLEY WILSON: on to the next question.
SHIRLEY WILSON: I've recently been doing some bespoke
SHIRLEY WILSON: training this year, particulary with
SHIRLEY WILSON: actually quite a few d/Deaf organisations.
SHIRLEY WILSON: It's been really positive that they've
SHIRLEY WILSON: been coming forward.
SHIRLEY WILSON: One of the things for me that I bring up
SHIRLEY WILSON: is the sign for abuse is
SHIRLEY WILSON: one: it's abuse.
SHIRLEY WILSON: You all know this, but I think the general
SHIRLEY WILSON: population just look at abuse.
SHIRLEY WILSON: What I've said to these d/Deaf adults,
SHIRLEY WILSON: because they work with d/Deaf young people
SHIRLEY WILSON: and children and their families, is: how
SHIRLEY WILSON: do you expect a child to be able to make a
SHIRLEY WILSON: disclosure if they think this [the BSL
SHIRLEY WILSON: sign for abuse] just means 'beating
SHIRLEY WILSON: up'. Where in actualy fact we need to go
SHIRLEY WILSON: into much greater detail about sexual
SHIRLEY WILSON: abuse, emotional abuse, neglect.
SHIRLEY WILSON: I'm
SHIRLEY WILSON: trying to get across to the d/Deaf
SHIRLEY WILSON: adult community, because I feel that they
SHIRLEY WILSON: also have a role to play in supporting the
SHIRLEY WILSON: work that happens out there.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Some of these organisations are absolutely
SHIRLEY WILSON: fantastic because they provide services
SHIRLEY WILSON: that the local authorities are unable to
SHIRLEY WILSON: provide now, so whether have the support
SHIRLEY WILSON: that they can help their groups.
SHIRLEY WILSON: And I feel that by them having a better
SHIRLEY WILSON: understanding, and when we have those
SHIRLEY WILSON: discussions about the word abuse, they
SHIRLEY WILSON: then start to unravel that.
SHIRLEY WILSON: I hope in time that that will then
SHIRLEY WILSON: filter down to the younger d/Deaf
SHIRLEY WILSON: population.
SHIRLEY WILSON: So I just wanted to add to that because I
SHIRLEY WILSON: think it really is quite critical.
ALYS YOUNG: We've talked a lot about the difficulties and
ALYS YOUNG: the problems. I'd like to throw in something
ALYS YOUNG: positive here, because I don't want somebody
ALYS YOUNG: looking at this podcast thinking every d/Deaf
ALYS YOUNG: child has a problem, you know, and every
ALYS YOUNG: d/Deaf child is likely to be abused.
ALYS YOUNG: I think one of the things that d/Deaf young
ALYS YOUNG: people do as peers — so when d/Deaf young
ALYS YOUNG: people are with other d/Deaf young people — is
ALYS YOUNG: that they can spot really quickly
ALYS YOUNG: whether there's something not quite right with
ALYS YOUNG: their friend or within their peer group.
ALYS YOUNG: And some of that acuity is a visual
ALYS YOUNG: acuity that hearing people don't have in the
ALYS YOUNG: same way. That visual recognition of
ALYS YOUNG: differences in facial expression, body tone,
ALYS YOUNG: nonverbal tone, that kind of thing.
ALYS YOUNG: The problem is that young d/Deaf people, as
ALYS YOUNG: peers, often don't know the route
ALYS YOUNG: to take their concerns.
ALYS YOUNG: So who is likely to believe them?
ALYS YOUNG: If they want to support their friend to say
ALYS YOUNG: something, who would that friend talk to?
ALYS YOUNG: Who is the trusted adult and the trusted
ALYS YOUNG: adult who can communicate?
ALYS YOUNG: Because we know from all the resilience
ALYS YOUNG: literature, for example, it just takes one
ALYS YOUNG: trusted adult that you feel comfortable
ALYS YOUNG: communicating with, and the young person's
ALYS YOUNG: world can just change.
ALYS YOUNG: But for d/Deaf young people, the number of
ALYS YOUNG: potentially trusted adults is a lot less,
ALYS YOUNG: particularly if, for example, abuse is
ALYS YOUNG: happening in a family.
ALYS YOUNG: And a family member that you might actually
ALYS YOUNG: feel comfortable with and want to talk to, you
ALYS YOUNG: just think you can't do that because they are
ALYS YOUNG: too closely connected with somebody who might
ALYS YOUNG: be creating an abusive situation.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Can I now move on to the next question, if
SHIRLEY WILSON: that's all right? Because I'm just conscious
SHIRLEY WILSON: we've got a lot we want to talk about
SHIRLEY WILSON: here. My next question is:
SHIRLEY WILSON: what barriers do you think might prevent
SHIRLEY WILSON: professionals from identifying
SHIRLEY WILSON: safeguarding concerns when working with
SHIRLEY WILSON: d/Deaf children and young people. Because
SHIRLEY WILSON: I think, obviously, you have a lot of
SHIRLEY WILSON: experience in that area.
TIM RICHARDSON: Alys already touched on that one of the
TIM RICHARDSON: barriers is having a route for a young
TIM RICHARDSON: person to express their concerns.
TIM RICHARDSON: And I suppose one of the things there is
TIM RICHARDSON: how do we facilitate communication
TIM RICHARDSON: generally and how do we create
TIM RICHARDSON: that space for a trusted person or a
TIM RICHARDSON: trusted dialogue, if you like?
TIM RICHARDSON: I think one of the barriers, historically
TIM RICHARDSON: and maybe still, is that
TIM RICHARDSON: there can be low expectations for d/Deaf
TIM RICHARDSON: children and young people that can be
TIM RICHARDSON: sometimes within families, and it can also
TIM RICHARDSON: be within professional groups.
TIM RICHARDSON: So what we would expect, for example,
TIM RICHARDSON: in terms of what language a young
TIM RICHARDSON: person or a child might have; that might
TIM RICHARDSON: be modified. And we've sadly seen
TIM RICHARDSON: actual cases where that is and that's led
TIM RICHARDSON: to tragic outcomes, where we've not
TIM RICHARDSON: accepted that it's not okay for a young
TIM RICHARDSON: person, d/Deaf or hearing to not have a
TIM RICHARDSON: language at the age of three.
TIM RICHARDSON: So, I think a lot of this — I mean,
TIM RICHARDSON: sometimes I feel a bit like a stuck record
TIM RICHARDSON: — but a lot of it comes back to language
TIM RICHARDSON: and communication and making sure we get
TIM RICHARDSON: that bedrock right.
TIM RICHARDSON: The effort should be on the part of us as
TIM RICHARDSON: professionals and the people around the
TIM RICHARDSON: child to create as many opportunities
TIM RICHARDSON: for that young person to express
TIM RICHARDSON: themselves in the way that is their
TIM RICHARDSON: preferred way.
JO HORNSBY: I was just thinking about all of the
JO HORNSBY: complications, just thinking about the
JO HORNSBY: process, you know, that a child
JO HORNSBY: and a family have had to go through, and
JO HORNSBY: there's so many complications in that process,
JO HORNSBY: isn't there.
JO HORNSBY: From the outset we've got children who have
JO HORNSBY: got those language and communication barriers,
JO HORNSBY: so they may not have the language to be able
JO HORNSBY: to name and tell
JO HORNSBY: us what is going on for them in the first
JO HORNSBY: place. Then, do they have a trusted
JO HORNSBY: person to go to to say that?
JO HORNSBY: And is that trusted person somehow
JO HORNSBY: incorporated in what's going on for them?
JO HORNSBY: That's a complication in itself.
JO HORNSBY: And then you've got to work
JO HORNSBY: the way through a potentially difficult
JO HORNSBY: system, where professionals are perhaps
JO HORNSBY: not having the awareness
JO HORNSBY: to then respond as that child needs them to
JO HORNSBY: respond. So there are so many complications,
JO HORNSBY: aren't there, along that route.
JO HORNSBY: And then, of course, if a child has made
JO HORNSBY: a disclosure, in order to then be able to
JO HORNSBY: progress with that situation and to
JO HORNSBY: take some action, and for there to be some
JO HORNSBY: outcome from it, you need the detail.
JO HORNSBY: You need the evidence. You need the child to
JO HORNSBY: be able to explain to you what has happened.
JO HORNSBY: And, of course, that's a highly complicated
JO HORNSBY: process and requires a deep
JO HORNSBY: understanding, as we've said, about how that
JO HORNSBY: child communicates. What's their preferred way
JO HORNSBY: of expressing that, and
JO HORNSBY: then having the awareness and ability to be
JO HORNSBY: able to respond to that. The professionals in
JO HORNSBY: that process need to have good awareness and
JO HORNSBY: good communication skills, and then access to
JO HORNSBY: interpreting services, interpreters
JO HORNSBY: who are appropriately trained, and can
JO HORNSBY: respond in the appropriate ways.
JO HORNSBY: So there's so many points along
JO HORNSBY: that process where things can
JO HORNSBY: fall down and where we don't manage
JO HORNSBY: to respond in the way that we should do for
JO HORNSBY: that child to get to the place where we need
JO HORNSBY: to be.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Thank you. I don't want to stop the
SHIRLEY WILSON: conversation, because I think the next
SHIRLEY WILSON: question actually is going to be
SHIRLEY WILSON: incorporating a lot of what you've already
SHIRLEY WILSON: started. I want to expand on that a bit
SHIRLEY WILSON: more, because I think the systematic
SHIRLEY WILSON: process of child protection procedures is
SHIRLEY WILSON: a big barrier. For me,
SHIRLEY WILSON: the next question I think — Tim, if I can
SHIRLEY WILSON: ask you to start this off — what do
SHIRLEY WILSON: you think professionals could do to
SHIRLEY WILSON: develop effective multi-agency
SHIRLEY WILSON: partnership, that not only considers
SHIRLEY WILSON: the needs, but for me it's about
SHIRLEY WILSON: how does it strengthen the response of
SHIRLEY WILSON: meaningful services? Crux of the matter,
SHIRLEY WILSON: it's about meaningful services to children
SHIRLEY WILSON: and their families.
TIM RICHARDSON: Yeah. I think it it goes...
TIM RICHARDSON: it links in with the work we've done
TIM RICHARDSON: within the group.
TIM RICHARDSON: It's thinking about doing things before.
TIM RICHARDSON: So establishing foundations,
TIM RICHARDSON: establishing networks locally, introducing
TIM RICHARDSON: the issues for d/Deaf children and young
TIM RICHARDSON: people to groups like in schools
TIM RICHARDSON: and social care.
TIM RICHARDSON: What you'll find is when you do that,
TIM RICHARDSON: there's always a cohort of people who are
TIM RICHARDSON: really interested, who really want to take
TIM RICHARDSON: up...
TIM RICHARDSON: pick up the panel with us, you know, sort
TIM RICHARDSON: of thing. Even if they haven't had BSL
TIM RICHARDSON: or they haven't got any prior knowledge of
TIM RICHARDSON: working with d/Deaf people, there are
TIM RICHARDSON: people who are genuinely captivated by it,
TIM RICHARDSON: who will be natural allies in terms
TIM RICHARDSON: of people to go to, whether that be in a
TIM RICHARDSON: social services department, or in health
TIM RICHARDSON: or in education. In general it is about, I
TIM RICHARDSON: think, there's something about their needs
TIM RICHARDSON: to be work beforehand to set up, to
TIM RICHARDSON: find where are our natural allies.
TIM RICHARDSON: Getting out there, doing a bit of
TIM RICHARDSON: awareness raising, as well as offering
TIM RICHARDSON: training where appropriate,
TIM RICHARDSON: and trying to build those.
TIM RICHARDSON: Now, there are natural places like the
TIM RICHARDSON: safeguarding boards and the like, where
TIM RICHARDSON: I think you could build that in.
JO HORNSBY: One of the things that, as a specialist worker
JO HORNSBY: and alongside my specialist colleagues,
JO HORNSBY: is that it's keeping deaf children on, on the
JO HORNSBY: agenda. Wherever you go it's
JO HORNSBY: making sure that it's mentioned and,
JO HORNSBY: you know, I think people get really fed up
JO HORNSBY: with us with doing that, but we do do that.
JO HORNSBY: Any meeting, any training, any
JO HORNSBY: place where people are coming together,
JO HORNSBY: you say "what about how would that be for a
JO HORNSBY: deaf child in that situation?" You know, let's
JO HORNSBY: think about that. So it's keeping
JO HORNSBY: the deaf children on the agenda.
JO HORNSBY: And I mean d/Deaf awareness was something that
JO HORNSBY: we used to do very frequently.
JO HORNSBY: And, of course, with the pressures — and this
JO HORNSBY: is the reality of the current times — is that
JO HORNSBY: those things like d/Deaf awareness training
JO HORNSBY: get pushed to the side a bit.
JO HORNSBY: And of course, it's so vital that that happens
JO HORNSBY: because it is through that...
JO HORNSBY: Yeah, we always used to come away with a
JO HORNSBY: little fan group that, as you said Tim,
JO HORNSBY: they are interested and they want to find
JO HORNSBY: out about it.
JO HORNSBY: Being able to continue to do that d/Deaf
JO HORNSBY: awareness training with colleagues is really
JO HORNSBY: vital, I think, particular to perhaps teams
JO HORNSBY: that are at that coalface, like the MASH for
JO HORNSBY: example, who are receiving those referrals
JO HORNSBY: in who really need to have that awareness.
JO HORNSBY: And of course it needs to be something that's
JO HORNSBY: ongoing, you can't just do it once and it's
JO HORNSBY: done. It needs to be something that's done
JO HORNSBY: over and over again, doesn't it?
JO HORNSBY: Because, you know, obviously information
JO HORNSBY: changes, but also workers move on and
JO HORNSBY: so there's different people who need to have
JO HORNSBY: that awareness.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Thank you very much.
ALYS YOUNG: Before I say my point, Jo, what's MASH?
JO HORNSBY: Oh MASH, sorry about that.
JO HORNSBY: They're the multi-agency safeguarding
JO HORNSBY: hub. So that's the team
JO HORNSBY: that receive those referrals
JO HORNSBY: and are then processing that.
JO HORNSBY: So yes, very important that they
JO HORNSBY: have that awareness.
ALYS YOUNG: Thanks for that. So the point I wanted to
ALYS YOUNG: make: Shirley, you're asking us, really,
ALYS YOUNG: about specialists as well
ALYS YOUNG: within this process.
ALYS YOUNG: I suppose I've got three points I want to
ALYS YOUNG: make. I absolutely, totally endorse what
ALYS YOUNG: everybody said about needing very high
ALYS YOUNG: quality, experienced interpreters
ALYS YOUNG: who know what they're doing in child
ALYS YOUNG: protection.
ALYS YOUNG: But interpreters do not solve the problem.
ALYS YOUNG: And I've met too many social work
ALYS YOUNG: professionals who think that they can manage
ALYS YOUNG: a quite serious child safeguarding incident
ALYS YOUNG: involving a d/Deaf child if they just bring an
ALYS YOUNG: interpreter in, and then all the difficulties
ALYS YOUNG: suddenly disappear.
ALYS YOUNG: So I'd really like to clearly say that's not
ALYS YOUNG: the case, because as all of us have said all
ALYS YOUNG: the way through this podcast, it's actually
ALYS YOUNG: you need to understand d/Deaf children.
ALYS YOUNG: You need to understand communication, language
ALYS YOUNG: development, d/Deaf child experience, if
ALYS YOUNG: you're going to be standing alongside that
ALYS YOUNG: child in such a difficult situation; but also
ALYS YOUNG: make sense of all of the steps in the
ALYS YOUNG: safeguarding process.
ALYS YOUNG: So an interpreter is vital — doesn't solve the
ALYS YOUNG: problem. There are, however, really good
ALYS YOUNG: d/Deaf professionals out there who are
ALYS YOUNG: incredibly well qualified as well.
ALYS YOUNG: They're quite rare, and sometimes they don't
ALYS YOUNG: work directly as social workers; sometimes
ALYS YOUNG: they do. I think there needs to be a point
ALYS YOUNG: at which somebody asks themselves, "where
ALYS YOUNG: is the d/Deaf person in this safeguarding
ALYS YOUNG: process or in this child protection process?"
ALYS YOUNG: Because whatever role that d/Deaf person is
ALYS YOUNG: playing professionally, they will bring some
ALYS YOUNG: things that hearing people do not have and can
ALYS YOUNG: never have.
ALYS YOUNG: And so where is the d/Deaf person in the
ALYS YOUNG: process professionally is a really important
ALYS YOUNG: question. And my last question, or my
ALYS YOUNG: last point, is a question I constantly asked
ALYS YOUNG: myself when I was in practice, which is what
ALYS YOUNG: is the limit of my expertise and
ALYS YOUNG: what is the limit of my knowledge?
ALYS YOUNG: So that process of reflection as a
ALYS YOUNG: professional, every step of the way, so that
ALYS YOUNG: you recognise when you can't do something,
ALYS YOUNG: when you don't know enough, when you need
ALYS YOUNG: another person in the room supporting you.
ALYS YOUNG: And I think there's not enough of that
ALYS YOUNG: questioning that happens these days because,
ALYS YOUNG: as Jo, you've already said, social work
ALYS YOUNG: departments are under huge pressure, so you
ALYS YOUNG: get allocated, you just do the job
ALYS YOUNG: and that scope for reflection and just
ALYS YOUNG: stopping and saying, "I'm not good enough, I
ALYS YOUNG: don't know enough." There's very little space
ALYS YOUNG: for that these days.
SHIRLEY WILSON: We have already talked about what is the
SHIRLEY WILSON: impact of disappearing specialist
SHIRLEY WILSON: knowledge in practice for working
SHIRLEY WILSON: with d/Deaf children, and we know that
SHIRLEY WILSON: from the social workers group.
SHIRLEY WILSON: So I just wonder who wants to answer this:
SHIRLEY WILSON: is there any miracle
SHIRLEY WILSON: that we can look at to addressing this in
SHIRLEY WILSON: current society.
JO HORNSBY: Yeah, I mean it's it's a really, really
JO HORNSBY: challenging question, isn't it?
JO HORNSBY: Because we know that the reality is
JO HORNSBY: that there's tremendous pressures on local
JO HORNSBY: authority children's services and the
JO HORNSBY: pressures are relentless.
JO HORNSBY: So the days of the specialist service feels
JO HORNSBY: like there's not going to be, you know, it
JO HORNSBY: feels to me like there's not going to be
JO HORNSBY: a great change in that right at the moment.
JO HORNSBY: So perhaps it is about, doing
JO HORNSBY: what we're doing already in terms of
JO HORNSBY: raising the awareness, keeping the subject
JO HORNSBY: on the agenda.
JO HORNSBY: I mean, for us — myself and my
JO HORNSBY: colleagues who were part of that specialist
JO HORNSBY: service and have that memory of that —
JO HORNSBY: one of the things that we do is we ensure that
JO HORNSBY: we keep those relationships going.
JO HORNSBY: We make sure that we liaise with our
JO HORNSBY: colleagues, the teachers of the d/Deaf,
JO HORNSBY: and colleagues in audiology, so that
JO HORNSBY: we're retaining that old model to some degree
JO HORNSBY: in terms of working together and talking
JO HORNSBY: things through and having those conversations
JO HORNSBY: about individual children.
JO HORNSBY: And I think that that helps.
TIM RICHARDSON: Yeah. I just wonder if it's such a
TIM RICHARDSON: significant gap, and the right thing
TIM RICHARDSON: is to have that specialist knowledge, then
TIM RICHARDSON: our efforts should be going to have that
TIM RICHARDSON: reinstated rather than trying to
TIM RICHARDSON: plug the gaps.
TIM RICHARDSON: And I think that we've kind of got
TIM RICHARDSON: into a way of working where that's what we
TIM RICHARDSON: do. We try and make up for what's
TIM RICHARDSON: missing by cobbling things together.
TIM RICHARDSON: I think it's worth, where we still
TIM RICHARDSON: have that, if we could evidence what
TIM RICHARDSON: difference that makes and be pushing for
TIM RICHARDSON: what should be in place rather than
TIM RICHARDSON: accepting that it's not in place and covering for it.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Thank you. Alys?
ALYS YOUNG: I agree with both of you.
ALYS YOUNG: I did some research about the demise of
ALYS YOUNG: specialist social work teams a few years ago.
ALYS YOUNG: One of our respondents described themselves
ALYS YOUNG: when I said, "what do you do?" They said, "I'm
ALYS YOUNG: a gap filler. I do the thing nobody else does
ALYS YOUNG: that d/Deaf children and families need.
ALYS YOUNG: And that's the definition of my job." In that
ALYS YOUNG: same piece of research, we asked many local
ALYS YOUNG: authorities to tell us who's the specialist
ALYS YOUNG: designated worker might be, because that's
ALYS YOUNG: somebody we needed to reach in order to do the
ALYS YOUNG: research.
ALYS YOUNG: Most, and I genuinely mean most,
ALYS YOUNG: couldn't tell us who their specialist social
ALYS YOUNG: work professional might be, because the system
ALYS YOUNG: said if there's a deaf child that comes to
ALYS YOUNG: notice around a child protection concern,
ALYS YOUNG: it goes into whatever the generic team is,
ALYS YOUNG: whether that's a children and families team or
ALYS YOUNG: disabilities team.
ALYS YOUNG: And that structure covers up
ALYS YOUNG: those pockets of specialism that still exist
ALYS YOUNG: as well, which is another problem in this.
ALYS YOUNG: But going back to your point, Tim.
ALYS YOUNG: I think we do need to evidence things a bit
ALYS YOUNG: more — I'm bound to say this working in a
ALYS YOUNG: research department, but nonetheless — we need
ALYS YOUNG: to evidence
ALYS YOUNG: the harm and the unnecessary
ALYS YOUNG: harm that happens to d/Deaf children
ALYS YOUNG: because of late recognition
ALYS YOUNG: when abuse happens, or because social services
ALYS YOUNG: are only able to respond to the most extreme
ALYS YOUNG: emergency or the most extreme manifestation
ALYS YOUNG: of harm.
ALYS YOUNG: And we also need to evidence good practice
ALYS YOUNG: because it's still there.
ALYS YOUNG: It's just very, very hidden.
ALYS YOUNG: So what difference is it making that people
ALYS YOUNG: like you, Jo, are working in the way you're
ALYS YOUNG: working?
ALYS YOUNG: How is that quantified?
ALYS YOUNG: And I know social workers are not that keen on
ALYS YOUNG: things being quantified, but actually
ALYS YOUNG: quantifying what makes a difference is
ALYS YOUNG: really important. And I think the third button
ALYS YOUNG: to press, if you like, is the 'rights' button.
ALYS YOUNG: So children's rights and understanding
ALYS YOUNG: the way in which services might not be
ALYS YOUNG: adequate from the perspective of the rights of
ALYS YOUNG: the child as opposed to what can a service
ALYS YOUNG: provide. So changing the framework
ALYS YOUNG: a little bit in how we talk about the problem.
ALYS YOUNG: I think that might create some pressure around
ALYS YOUNG: supporting specialist social work development
ALYS YOUNG: a bit more.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Thank you very much indeed for your
SHIRLEY WILSON: contributions. I think this is a good
SHIRLEY WILSON: place now to actually conclude our
SHIRLEY WILSON: discussion.
SHIRLEY WILSON: I want to say a massive thank you very
SHIRLEY WILSON: much to Tim Richardson, Professor
SHIRLEY WILSON: Alys Young, and Jo Hornsby for joining us
SHIRLEY WILSON: today. And I hope this has been a really
SHIRLEY WILSON: useful podcast for moving on.
SHIRLEY WILSON: Thank you very much indeed for all of your
SHIRLEY WILSON: time.
OUTRO: Thanks for listening to this NSPCC learning
OUTRO: Podcast.
OUTRO: At the time of recording, this episode's content
OUTRO: was up to date, but the world of safeguarding and
OUTRO: child protection is ever-changing.
OUTRO: So, if you're looking for the most current
OUTRO: safeguarding and child protection training,
OUTRO: information or resources, please visit
OUTRO: our website for professionals at nspcc.org/learning.
We recommend upgrading to the latest Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
Please check your internet connection and refresh the page. You might also try disabling any ad blockers.
You can visit our support center if you're having problems.