PRODUCER: Please note this podcast contains mention of
PRODUCER: child sexual abuse.
PRODUCER: In 2015, the Independent Inquiry into Child
PRODUCER: Sexual Abuse was set up to investigate where
PRODUCER: institutions failed to protect children in their
PRODUCER: care.
PRODUCER: The inquiry's final report, published in October
PRODUCER: 2022, laid out a set of powerful recommendations
PRODUCER: to address past failings and protect future
PRODUCER: generations of children from abuse.
PRODUCER: Recommendations for Change is a five part
PRODUCER: podcast series from NSPCC Learning, examining
PRODUCER: why these recommendations are needed, how
PRODUCER: they'll work if implemented, and what impact
PRODUCER: they will have on the prevention of child sexual
PRODUCER: abuse.
PRODUCER: Episode four: online safety.
PRODUCER: Being online is an integral part of children and
PRODUCER: young people's lives, but it can expose them to
PRODUCER: risks, including sexual abuse.
PRODUCER: The past five years has seen a proliferation in
PRODUCER: child sexual abuse (CSA) material online
PRODUCER: data from the Internet Watch Foundation, the UK
PRODUCER: hotline for reporting and removing online child
PRODUCER: sexual abuse material, shows that the number of
PRODUCER: reports of web pages assessed as containing CSA
PRODUCER: increased from 78,000 in 2017
PRODUCER: to 255,000 in
PRODUCER: 2022.
PRODUCER: IICSA published an investigation report into the
PRODUCER: growing problem of online-facilitated CSA
PRODUCER: in March 2020.
PRODUCER: It investigated the response of law enforcement,
PRODUCER: industry and government to three types of
PRODUCER: offending: indecent images of children offences,
PRODUCER: the grooming of a child, and live streaming of
PRODUCER: child sexual abuse.
PRODUCER: It found that whilst the last five years have
PRODUCER: seen improvements in the responses to these
PRODUCER: issues, there was no evidence to suggest a
PRODUCER: decrease in online child sexual abuse offences
PRODUCER: and, quote, "law enforcement is struggling
PRODUCER: to keep pace".
PRODUCER: A step forward was made in October 2023
PRODUCER: with the passing of the Online Safety Act, which
PRODUCER: gives online service providers new legal
PRODUCER: responsibilities to keep children safe on their
PRODUCER: platforms. However, there is still much work
PRODUCER: that needs to be done in order to eradicate
PRODUCER: child sexual abuse online.
PRODUCER: In this episode, we will be exploring the scale
PRODUCER: of the online abuse problem and how the
PRODUCER: recommendations seek to tackle the issue.
PRODUCER: Susie Hargreaves is the Chief Executive of the
PRODUCER: Internet Watch Foundation.
PRODUCER: We spoke to Susie about the importance of
PRODUCER: implementing strong online protections for
PRODUCER: children in October 2023, a couple
PRODUCER: of weeks before the Online Safety Act was signed
PRODUCER: into law.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: The internet is a really positive space,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: and of course, children get so much out
SUSIE HARGREAVES: of use of the internet, their
SUSIE HARGREAVES: entertainment, their social networking,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: their education. But unfortunately it
SUSIE HARGREAVES: has a really dark side as well, which
SUSIE HARGREAVES: is that children are very easily
SUSIE HARGREAVES: exploited on the internet, and, without
SUSIE HARGREAVES: protections being put in place, there
SUSIE HARGREAVES: will always be people who will try and
SUSIE HARGREAVES: take advantage of the most vulnerable
SUSIE HARGREAVES: people in society.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So, we would always say, you know, it's
SUSIE HARGREAVES: not that technology is bad, it's not
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that the internet is bad, but the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: reality is that there is a lot of very,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: very bad stuff on the internet, and we
SUSIE HARGREAVES: need to do everything we can to keep our
SUSIE HARGREAVES: children safe.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Now, the IWF, the area I work with, we
SUSIE HARGREAVES: deal with illegal content, so we're
SUSIE HARGREAVES: dealing with the very worst of the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: content. So this is illegal content.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: It's illegal for everybody.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: It's illegal to make, to share,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to distribute and to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: produce. So, you know, basically we need
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to make sure that nobody has access to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: this content. But of course, looking at
SUSIE HARGREAVES: this content is not the worst thing.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: The worst thing is that actually
SUSIE HARGREAVES: children are sexually abused in the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: making of this content. And in fact,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: every single time somebody looks at that
SUSIE HARGREAVES: content, that child is revictimised,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: their abuse reoccurs,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: and it's not a victimless crime.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So what we need to do is do everything
SUSIE HARGREAVES: we can to put safety protections around
SUSIE HARGREAVES: children online so that this really
SUSIE HARGREAVES: hideous, heinous crime doesn't happen
SUSIE HARGREAVES: because children carry it with them for
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the rest of their lives.
PRODUCER: What does the IICSA final report say about the
PRODUCER: challenge presented by online-facilitated child
PRODUCER: sexual abuse?
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Well, the IICSA final report made a
SUSIE HARGREAVES: number of recommendations.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Obviously only a few of them were
SUSIE HARGREAVES: related to online child sexual abuse.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: We were privileged enough to be
SUSIE HARGREAVES: co-participants in the IICSA inquiry on
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the online space, and it was very clear
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that we needed to put some specific
SUSIE HARGREAVES: protections in place for children.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Of course, this was aligned to what was
SUSIE HARGREAVES: happening at that time. The Online
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Safety Bill was going through Parliament
SUSIE HARGREAVES: at the time, and actually IICSA was
SUSIE HARGREAVES: taking that into account.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So specifically on the online space, it
SUSIE HARGREAVES: made a number of recommendations.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: The first, which totally relates to our
SUSIE HARGREAVES: area of work, was the need to screen
SUSIE HARGREAVES: for child sexual abuse.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So instead of sort of just relying on
SUSIE HARGREAVES: people might do it, companies might do
SUSIE HARGREAVES: it. There would then be, a commitment
SUSIE HARGREAVES: from companies to have to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: pre-screen/screen to ensure that child
SUSIE HARGREAVES: sexual abuse did not go onto their
SUSIE HARGREAVES: platforms using a range of technologies
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to enable them to do that.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: And that was really important for us.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: The second was the age verification
SUSIE HARGREAVES: side. So whilst the IWF is not
SUSIE HARGREAVES: an organisation that deals with
SUSIE HARGREAVES: inappropriate content that children are
SUSIE HARGREAVES: accessing, we are also, co-directors
SUSIE HARGREAVES: of the UK's Safer Internet Centre, so
SUSIE HARGREAVES: obviously we care very, very much about
SUSIE HARGREAVES: children's access to that material.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So we want to ensure that children do
SUSIE HARGREAVES: not have access to pornography.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: We also want to ensure that children who
SUSIE HARGREAVES: are under 13 don't have access
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to social media.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So we really want to see robust
SUSIE HARGREAVES: age verification and age appropriate
SUSIE HARGREAVES: tools put in place on the online safety
SUSIE HARGREAVES: bill. And the third was the CSE/A, the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Child Sexual Exploitation and Abuse Code
SUSIE HARGREAVES: of practice, which of course, is, under
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the Online Safety Bill.
PRODUCER: You mentioned the Online Safety Bill, which is
PRODUCER: soon to be given royal assent and will become
PRODUCER: the Online Safety Act.
PRODUCER: How does the Online Safety Act dovetail with the
PRODUCER: final recommendations?
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Now, prior to the, bill going through
SUSIE HARGREAVES: in relation to online child sexual
SUSIE HARGREAVES: abuse, companies worked on a voluntary
SUSIE HARGREAVES: basis. So they were
SUSIE HARGREAVES: obliged kind of morally to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: do what they could to keep their
SUSIE HARGREAVES: platforms clean of child sexual abuse,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: or to do as much as they possibly could
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to ensure that it didn't get loaded onto
SUSIE HARGREAVES: their platforms, but there was no kind
SUSIE HARGREAVES: of transparency or accountability around
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that. Now, what's really important about
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the Online Safety Bill is that will no
SUSIE HARGREAVES: longer be a voluntary thing, but they
SUSIE HARGREAVES: will actually have to legally comply
SUSIE HARGREAVES: with that. So they will have to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: demonstrate, how they are doing
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the best they can to keep their
SUSIE HARGREAVES: platforms as clean as possible.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: And that will be to ensure that there
SUSIE HARGREAVES: are robust online safety tools,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that there are robust tech solutions.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So we provide a number
SUSIE HARGREAVES: of tech solutions to companies.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So when we talk about screening
SUSIE HARGREAVES: platforms, what we're talking about is
SUSIE HARGREAVES: we provide things like a hash list,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: which is a list of digital fingerprints
SUSIE HARGREAVES: of known child sexual abuse images — we
SUSIE HARGREAVES: currently have about 1.2 million of
SUSIE HARGREAVES: these — and companies will deploy
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that across their platform to stop
SUSIE HARGREAVES: anybody uploading a duplicate image.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: If it has a match, it won't go onto the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: platform. So that's really important so
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that that content doesn't get onto the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: platform to begin with.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: We also provide things like a blocking
SUSIE HARGREAVES: list, a URL list, a list of web pages
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that currently contain child sexual
SUSIE HARGREAVES: abuse and haven't been removed from the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: internet yet. They will be obliged to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: make sure that people can't access that
SUSIE HARGREAVES: material.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: It's really important that these
SUSIE HARGREAVES: elements of the IICSA report, which
SUSIE HARGREAVES: raised awareness of the fact that that a
SUSIE HARGREAVES: lot of companies weren't doing that,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: they now will be legally obliged to do
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that. The other thing that's important
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to say in relation to how the Online
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Safety Act, as it will be, in a couple
SUSIE HARGREAVES: of weeks, dovetails with the IICSA final
SUSIE HARGREAVES: report, is an awful lot of the detail
SUSIE HARGREAVES: has yet to be worked through.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So, whilst we have some fundamental
SUSIE HARGREAVES: principles in place around the Online
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Safety Act, the actual operational side
SUSIE HARGREAVES: is really still to play for.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So we need to ensure that when the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: consultation comes out, and they'll be
SUSIE HARGREAVES: dealing with illegal material in the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: first instance, which is the area we
SUSIE HARGREAVES: work in, but some of the sort of
SUSIE HARGREAVES: knottier, more difficult questions
SUSIE HARGREAVES: around harmful content and making sure
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that we keep children safe online have
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to be worked through. So it's not a job
SUSIE HARGREAVES: done yet. And that's why it's really
SUSIE HARGREAVES: important to keep the pressure on about
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the IICSA recommendations, because we
SUSIE HARGREAVES: are all, across the child protection
SUSIE HARGREAVES: spectrum, online and offline, we're
SUSIE HARGREAVES: working together to keep people focused
SUSIE HARGREAVES: on these are our recommendation.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: These are the things we want to see.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: And we can't just sit there and be
SUSIE HARGREAVES: complacent and think, well, the Online
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Safety Bill is done and dusted, so
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that's going to cover everything.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So there's still a lot of work to do.
PRODUCER: And finally, what can professionals working with
PRODUCER: children and young people do to keep them safe
PRODUCER: online?
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Well, one of the things we would always
SUSIE HARGREAVES: say about the ways in which
SUSIE HARGREAVES: professionals working with children and
SUSIE HARGREAVES: young people can help them keep safe
SUSIE HARGREAVES: online is that it's not just a one
SUSIE HARGREAVES: thing is the solution.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: You know, actually you have to take a
SUSIE HARGREAVES: joint approach. So, we work in
SUSIE HARGREAVES: technology. Now technology is part of
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the solution. It's a major part of the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: solution. And the internet companies
SUSIE HARGREAVES: have got a lot more to do to ensure that
SUSIE HARGREAVES: they keep children safe online.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: But that's not the whole picture.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: We also need to have proper legislative
SUSIE HARGREAVES: and law enforcement support.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Hopefully this will be resolved through
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the Online Safety Bill.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: But also we need a really strong
SUSIE HARGREAVES: education and awareness programme.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: And that's why it's really important
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that a lot of us work together.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So the IWF, the organisation I lead,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: we are very much dealing with technical
SUSIE HARGREAVES: solutions, but it's really important we
SUSIE HARGREAVES: work with organisations like the NSPCC,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: because we don't deal directly with
SUSIE HARGREAVES: children, we don't have that level of
SUSIE HARGREAVES: expertise, but we can share our
SUSIE HARGREAVES: knowledge between us. And that's really
SUSIE HARGREAVES: important. And a great example of that
SUSIE HARGREAVES: is that we run a project called Report
SUSIE HARGREAVES: Remove together, where we enable young
SUSIE HARGREAVES: people to self-refer nudes of themselves
SUSIE HARGREAVES: for us to get them removed, to stop them
SUSIE HARGREAVES: being criminalised and to get those
SUSIE HARGREAVES: taken off the internet. We deal with the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: kind of technical, how do you take it
SUSIE HARGREAVES: down off the internet, and the NSPCC
SUSIE HARGREAVES: deal with the safeguarding aspect, but
SUSIE HARGREAVES: we join together on some of the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: education and awareness around that.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So I think what's really important is
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that everybody works together and we
SUSIE HARGREAVES: recognise that there isn't a single
SUSIE HARGREAVES: solution to this.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: But the other thing we really feel
SUSIE HARGREAVES: strongly — and I know this is shared
SUSIE HARGREAVES: across the board — that parents and
SUSIE HARGREAVES: carers, they do have a responsibility to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: make sure they do the best to keep
SUSIE HARGREAVES: children safe online.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: And you can't just bury your head in the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: sand on this. So, in the same ways you
SUSIE HARGREAVES: would on any element of children's
SUSIE HARGREAVES: safety, you need to not
SUSIE HARGREAVES: be scared by the internet.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: There's lots of help out there.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: There's lots of resources.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: There's lots of practical know-how
SUSIE HARGREAVES: points to help you keep yourself safe
SUSIE HARGREAVES: online. And one of the things we've
SUSIE HARGREAVES: discovered through the research we've
SUSIE HARGREAVES: done is that, you know, one meaningful
SUSIE HARGREAVES: conversation can make all the
SUSIE HARGREAVES: difference. So it's really important
SUSIE HARGREAVES: that people talk about that.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So you have to think about and learn
SUSIE HARGREAVES: about platforms that your children are
SUSIE HARGREAVES: on. You have to talk to them about what
SUSIE HARGREAVES: they're doing. You have to set family
SUSIE HARGREAVES: rules and family guidelines that
SUSIE HARGREAVES: everybody sticks to, and you have to
SUSIE HARGREAVES: take a sensible approach to this.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: But I think being scared of the internet
SUSIE HARGREAVES: is not helpful. Let's just all accept
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the internet is a wonderful thing,
SUSIE HARGREAVES: wonderful. But we have a responsibility
SUSIE HARGREAVES: to tackle that really dangerous, unsafe
SUSIE HARGREAVES: element. And if you've got a six- or
SUSIE HARGREAVES: seven-year-old, they really shouldn't be
SUSIE HARGREAVES: in that bedroom on their own with a
SUSIE HARGREAVES: camera-enabled device and an internet
SUSIE HARGREAVES: connection without supervision.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: So don't think just because they're in
SUSIE HARGREAVES: your house that they're safe.
SUSIE HARGREAVES: You have a responsibility to know what
SUSIE HARGREAVES: they're doing. But don't panic because
SUSIE HARGREAVES: the help is out there as well.
PRODUCER: As Susie said earlier, the Online Safety Act
PRODUCER: introduces legal requirements for companies to
PRODUCER: prevent illegal content from appearing on their
PRODUCER: platforms. This includes content depicting,
PRODUCER: promoting or facilitating child sexual abuse.
PRODUCER: If age inappropriate content, such as
PRODUCER: pornography, is present on a platform, companies
PRODUCER: must also use age verification tools to prevent
PRODUCER: children from accessing this content.
PRODUCER: This can be seen as a fulfilment of IICSA's
PRODUCER: recommendations on online safety.
PRODUCER: Recommendation 12 proposes that providers of
PRODUCER: internet search services and user-to-user
PRODUCER: services pre-screen uploaded content
PRODUCER: for known child sexual abuse material.
PRODUCER: Recommendation 20 proposes that the UK
PRODUCER: government change the law to make sure that
PRODUCER: social media platforms and other companies that
PRODUCER: provide online services introduce better age
PRODUCER: verification measures.
PRODUCER: However, as Susie says, we will have to wait and
PRODUCER: see whether this legislation has the desired
PRODUCER: effect or whether more steps are needed to
PRODUCER: tackle online-facilitated CSA.
PRODUCER: I wanted to find out more about how law
PRODUCER: enforcement responds to online-facilitated child
PRODUCER: sexual abuse, so I spoke to Ian Critchley, the
PRODUCER: National Police Chiefs Council lead for child
PRODUCER: protection.
IAN CRITCHLEY: I genuinely feel this is one of the most
IAN CRITCHLEY: critical areas in society that we are now
IAN CRITCHLEY: now dealing with: the explosion of the
IAN CRITCHLEY: internet. As we know, it's a real positive
IAN CRITCHLEY: with opportunities for us all, and
IAN CRITCHLEY: particularly for young people, but also
IAN CRITCHLEY: brings with it a great threat and challenge
IAN CRITCHLEY: that we must we must address.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And it's that area that I feel that we have
IAN CRITCHLEY: a great responsibility for, both law
IAN CRITCHLEY: enforcement and our partners, parents and
IAN CRITCHLEY: carers — and I'm a parent of three children
IAN CRITCHLEY: myself — but also, most importantly, the
IAN CRITCHLEY: industry and the companies who should take
IAN CRITCHLEY: the greatest responsibility.
IAN CRITCHLEY: The accessibility now to young people,
IAN CRITCHLEY: 12- to 15-year-olds.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And there's a doubling of, since 2011,
IAN CRITCHLEY: of access to smartphones.
IAN CRITCHLEY: So we will be in the 90% now of 12- to
IAN CRITCHLEY: 15-year-olds, but of 8- to 11-year-olds;
IAN CRITCHLEY: we're over 20% now of 8- to 11-year-olds
IAN CRITCHLEY: who have a social media account.
IAN CRITCHLEY: So we must ensure that we protect young
IAN CRITCHLEY: people from harm.
IAN CRITCHLEY: What does that harm look like?
IAN CRITCHLEY: It is of the highest level, from adults
IAN CRITCHLEY: who seek to groom exploit young children
IAN CRITCHLEY: by meeting with them, having facilitated
IAN CRITCHLEY: meetings online, seek to blackmail
IAN CRITCHLEY: them to share further images of themselves.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And we see some of the worst offending that
IAN CRITCHLEY: we know has huge, huge impact for the rest
IAN CRITCHLEY: of children's lives. And clearly, myself,
IAN CRITCHLEY: my colleagues, NCA, other law enforcement,
IAN CRITCHLEY: both in the UK and around the country, are
IAN CRITCHLEY: working tirelessly to identify these
IAN CRITCHLEY: offenders.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We're also seeing a rise in relation to
IAN CRITCHLEY: peer-on-peer offending.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We saw from the Everyone's Invited
IAN CRITCHLEY: campaign, which called out offending
IAN CRITCHLEY: within the school, particularly within the
IAN CRITCHLEY: school environment, of high harm offences
IAN CRITCHLEY: that were being committed between peers
IAN CRITCHLEY: of which there is absolutely criminal
IAN CRITCHLEY: justice route for high harm offending.
IAN CRITCHLEY: But what we also saw was what we say is a
IAN CRITCHLEY: normalisation of behaviour in
IAN CRITCHLEY: this area. So what do I mean by that?
IAN CRITCHLEY: Young people taking imagery of themselves,
IAN CRITCHLEY: self-generated imagery, sharing it with
IAN CRITCHLEY: their partners, consensual partners.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And of course, they might be the partners
IAN CRITCHLEY: at the time but clearly once an image is shared,
IAN CRITCHLEY: it can be lost and therefore used across
IAN CRITCHLEY: the internet in many different ways.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We don't want to criminalise young people
IAN CRITCHLEY: in this area. It's important that we're
IAN CRITCHLEY: able to safeguard and protect them
IAN CRITCHLEY: as well.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And this is just where we are now, clearly,
IAN CRITCHLEY: on top of that, we have a growing
IAN CRITCHLEY: development of artificial intelligence,
IAN CRITCHLEY: children going into what we call the
IAN CRITCHLEY: metaverse as well, young children going
IAN CRITCHLEY: into, you know, social media, gaming,
IAN CRITCHLEY: and not knowing who they are dealing with
IAN CRITCHLEY: or confronting.
IAN CRITCHLEY: So, really important that we take our
IAN CRITCHLEY: responsibilities as law enforcement and
IAN CRITCHLEY: partners, really important as parents and
IAN CRITCHLEY: carers that we have those challenging
IAN CRITCHLEY: conversations — I know how difficult they
IAN CRITCHLEY: are, but we have them — and give trust and
IAN CRITCHLEY: confidence to the young people to engage.
IAN CRITCHLEY: But most importantly, that industry
IAN CRITCHLEY: steps up to the mark, much more so than
IAN CRITCHLEY: it's doing now. And I really welcome the
IAN CRITCHLEY: Online Safety Bill and the impact of that
IAN CRITCHLEY: should have for you.
PRODUCER: For you, do the IICSA recommendations on online
PRODUCER: safety go far enough?
IAN CRITCHLEY: I think IICSA really identified
IAN CRITCHLEY: the critical issues here for us all,
IAN CRITCHLEY: working together, that young people are
IAN CRITCHLEY: facing now in an ever changing society.
IAN CRITCHLEY: So I think it fulfilled its role in making
IAN CRITCHLEY: the recommendations and dovetailing across
IAN CRITCHLEY: into the Online Safety Bill, without
IAN CRITCHLEY: seeking to try and duplicate or replicate
IAN CRITCHLEY: what needs to be coming in law.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And it's that aspect that is absolutely
IAN CRITCHLEY: crucial to make sure that companies are
IAN CRITCHLEY: able to prevent, first of all, the loading
IAN CRITCHLEY: of child abuse material onto their
IAN CRITCHLEY: platforms that they make millions and
IAN CRITCHLEY: billions of pounds from.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We're not talking just about, you know,
IAN CRITCHLEY: we're not talking about dark web here.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We are talking three clicks.
IAN CRITCHLEY: Three clicks — which again was highlighted
IAN CRITCHLEY: in the report — to access child abuse
IAN CRITCHLEY: material.
IAN CRITCHLEY: So first of all, stop it being on their
IAN CRITCHLEY: platforms in the first place.
IAN CRITCHLEY: Secondly, a legal duty to
IAN CRITCHLEY: identify and report to
IAN CRITCHLEY: the authorities once it's there.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And thirdly, to remove it from their
IAN CRITCHLEY: platforms, as well. We do have, to some
IAN CRITCHLEY: extent, good engagement with industry where
IAN CRITCHLEY: this happens, particularly with partnerships
IAN CRITCHLEY: with, for example, the Internet Watch
IAN CRITCHLEY: Foundation, in order to be able to report
IAN CRITCHLEY: and remove this material. But it is...
IAN CRITCHLEY: We are talking about the tip of an iceberg
IAN CRITCHLEY: when we consider the extent of offending
IAN CRITCHLEY: that I've outlined already.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And, no matter what is done — by
IAN CRITCHLEY: parents, carers, by law enforcement
IAN CRITCHLEY: — until industry plays its role, not
IAN CRITCHLEY: because they're forced to, because there are
IAN CRITCHLEY: legal duties. Because for me, they should
IAN CRITCHLEY: have a moral duty to make sure that
IAN CRITCHLEY: those people who are using their platforms,
IAN CRITCHLEY: that they have created these communities,
IAN CRITCHLEY: they have a moral duty to keep those
IAN CRITCHLEY: communities safe.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And if they don't, frankly, then they'll
IAN CRITCHLEY: find that people will walk away, quite
IAN CRITCHLEY: rightly, from that.
IAN CRITCHLEY: I believe this area, the online area,
IAN CRITCHLEY: also much wider than we're talking about
IAN CRITCHLEY: child abuse, because of course, we've seen
IAN CRITCHLEY: children access to other harmful material.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We've seen the impact on suicides in some
IAN CRITCHLEY: really dreadful cases that have been
IAN CRITCHLEY: highlighted in the news and inquests that
IAN CRITCHLEY: have taken place as a result of the
IAN CRITCHLEY: impact of harmful material that young
IAN CRITCHLEY: people have seen.
IAN CRITCHLEY: But I genuinely feel this is one of the
IAN CRITCHLEY: biggest public health issues facing
IAN CRITCHLEY: children. I'm really grateful for
IAN CRITCHLEY: the panel within IICSA making this
IAN CRITCHLEY: area really prominent.
IAN CRITCHLEY: I also believe it will feature prominently
IAN CRITCHLEY: in the rewrite of Working Together
IAN CRITCHLEY: that is ongoing and being consulted with at
IAN CRITCHLEY: this moment in time.
IAN CRITCHLEY: I don't think at this moment partners
IAN CRITCHLEY: consider the threats around online
IAN CRITCHLEY: probably quite as much as we do in terms of
IAN CRITCHLEY: some more traditional threats around child
IAN CRITCHLEY: protection. But I think that is starting to
IAN CRITCHLEY: change. And we take a responsibility for
IAN CRITCHLEY: that.
PRODUCER: And you mentioned the Online Safety Bill
PRODUCER: earlier. Does this piece of legislation do
PRODUCER: enough to address CSA?
PRODUCER: There are concerns around the ability to enforce
PRODUCER: the proposals laid out in a technology space
PRODUCER: where end-to-end encryption exists, for example.
IAN CRITCHLEY: I do believe it's an effective piece of
IAN CRITCHLEY: legislation. Clearly it's only effective
IAN CRITCHLEY: subject to how then it is implemented and
IAN CRITCHLEY: how it is regulated. And Ofcom are clearly
IAN CRITCHLEY: the main regulatory body in this regard.
IAN CRITCHLEY: The main duty in relation to child sexual
IAN CRITCHLEY: abuse is the necessity to prevent,
IAN CRITCHLEY: report and remove around
IAN CRITCHLEY: it. I think the first year or two will
IAN CRITCHLEY: require companies to outline
IAN CRITCHLEY: to Ofcom how they are going to mitigate and
IAN CRITCHLEY: manage that risk of harm.
IAN CRITCHLEY: They will have a specific duty around risk
IAN CRITCHLEY: assessments. They will have to demonstrate
IAN CRITCHLEY: how they are proactively identifying child
IAN CRITCHLEY: sexual abuse material and how they are
IAN CRITCHLEY: seeking to take reasonable steps
IAN CRITCHLEY: with technology to prevent it in the first
IAN CRITCHLEY: place. And I think that's going to be
IAN CRITCHLEY: absolutely the key in terms of what and who
IAN CRITCHLEY: defines what reasonable steps are being
IAN CRITCHLEY: used to prevent it.
IAN CRITCHLEY: I am concerned around the impact of
IAN CRITCHLEY: end-to-end encryption.
IAN CRITCHLEY: That seems to separate the need
IAN CRITCHLEY: and the societal need to protect children,
IAN CRITCHLEY: being pitched against a privacy argument.
IAN CRITCHLEY: This isn't the privacy issue.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And I totally understand the necessity for
IAN CRITCHLEY: privacy for young people, but there are
IAN CRITCHLEY: sufficient technical, enablers
IAN CRITCHLEY: to allow privacy and contact between
IAN CRITCHLEY: consenting people to that that protects
IAN CRITCHLEY: children and identifies offenders.
IAN CRITCHLEY: It's unfortunate that the language is being
IAN CRITCHLEY: used to try and conflict the two.
IAN CRITCHLEY: All of us have a duty to protect and
IAN CRITCHLEY: safeguard children.
IAN CRITCHLEY: There will be a legal duty to do that for
IAN CRITCHLEY: the companies. They cannot water that down,
IAN CRITCHLEY: or should not be able to water that down,
IAN CRITCHLEY: by saying, "well, we've brought end-to-end
IAN CRITCHLEY: encryption in and therefore we can't see
IAN CRITCHLEY: what's going on on our platforms. Therefore,
IAN CRITCHLEY: how can we prevent it or how can we report
IAN CRITCHLEY: it or remove it?" They have the technical
IAN CRITCHLEY: capabilities to ensure there is
IAN CRITCHLEY: encryption of message yet to be able to
IAN CRITCHLEY: identify, report and remove
IAN CRITCHLEY: indecent images of children.
IAN CRITCHLEY: That is a must. That is my concern.
IAN CRITCHLEY: I think my other concern is the speed in
IAN CRITCHLEY: which we move from implementation and
IAN CRITCHLEY: enactment to be able to identify
IAN CRITCHLEY: non-compliance around it.
IAN CRITCHLEY: So, the duty for companies to manage
IAN CRITCHLEY: and mitigate risk, to complete risk
IAN CRITCHLEY: assessments, to demonstrate what they're
IAN CRITCHLEY: doing, and then for Ofcom to assess that
IAN CRITCHLEY: and then determine and identify where there
IAN CRITCHLEY: is non-compliance; I'm just concerned about
IAN CRITCHLEY: the time scale. I think this area is moving
IAN CRITCHLEY: so quick. We're already talking about— it's
IAN CRITCHLEY: not something in the future when we're talking
IAN CRITCHLEY: about artificial intelligence and virtual
IAN CRITCHLEY: reality. It's already here.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We're already seeing child sexual abuse
IAN CRITCHLEY: material within the metaverse.
IAN CRITCHLEY: We are dealing with a huge increase in what
IAN CRITCHLEY: will start to become an even bigger
IAN CRITCHLEY: increase of demand in that area.
IAN CRITCHLEY: And ultimately, where should we really be
IAN CRITCHLEY: in this area? We should be preventing it
IAN CRITCHLEY: rather than having to respond to it in the
IAN CRITCHLEY: first place. I often will get and accept
IAN CRITCHLEY: and acknowledge the need for law enforcement
IAN CRITCHLEY: to step forward. We've worked with Her
IAN CRITCHLEY: Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary and
IAN CRITCHLEY: Fire and Rescue Service to take forward
IAN CRITCHLEY: recommendations for policing, so I
IAN CRITCHLEY: acknowledge and take responsibility, as the
IAN CRITCHLEY: national lead, that policing needs to do
IAN CRITCHLEY: much more.
IAN CRITCHLEY: But being able to predict the demand that
IAN CRITCHLEY: we've got here, being able to deal with
IAN CRITCHLEY: this, as well as many of the things that
IAN CRITCHLEY: policing needs to do, being able to
IAN CRITCHLEY: concentrate on those who are committing the
IAN CRITCHLEY: highest level of harm will best be done if
IAN CRITCHLEY: industry prevents such material being on
IAN CRITCHLEY: their platforms in the first place.
IAN CRITCHLEY: It will still be there; people will still
IAN CRITCHLEY: find their way to the dark web and other
IAN CRITCHLEY: areas but absolutely it will make it safer
IAN CRITCHLEY: for children. It will mean that it reduces
IAN CRITCHLEY: volume demand on us, and it will mean we
IAN CRITCHLEY: can concentrate on those who are committing
IAN CRITCHLEY: the highest level of harm.
IAN CRITCHLEY: It's a real challenge, but one in which we
IAN CRITCHLEY: must all strive to make sure that that
IAN CRITCHLEY: community, that online community, is
IAN CRITCHLEY: as safe as we would want our streets and
IAN CRITCHLEY: our neighbourhoods to be.
PRODUCER: Thanks to Ian Critchley and Susie Hargreaves.
PRODUCER: You can find a link to the Internet Watch
PRODUCER: Foundation's latest annual report in the podcast
PRODUCER: show notes.
PRODUCER: For more online safety advice, visit
PRODUCER: nspcc.org.uk/onlinesafety.
PRODUCER: In the next episode of Recommendations for
PRODUCER: Change, we'll be looking at justice and redress.
PRODUCER: What can be done to improve victims and
PRODUCER: survivors experiences of the criminal justice
PRODUCER: system?
PRODUCER: If you've been affected by any of the issues
PRODUCER: raised in this podcast, you can reach out to the
PRODUCER: NSPCC Helpline for support, call
PRODUCER: 0808 800 5000
PRODUCER: or email help@nspcc.org.uk.
PRODUCER: This podcast series was produced in Autumn 2023.
PRODUCER: All information was correct at the time of
PRODUCER: recording, but the world of child protection is
PRODUCER: ever-changing.
PRODUCER: To stay up to date, visit the NSPCC Learning
PRODUCER: website at nspcc.org.uk/learning.
We recommend upgrading to the latest Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
Please check your internet connection and refresh the page. You might also try disabling any ad blockers.
You can visit our support center if you're having problems.