Was Ron Logan The Real Delphi Murderer?
Oct 11, 2023, 07:00 PM
In the latest episode of the podcast "Hidden Killers," Tony Brueski dived deep into the case that has haunted many: the murders of Abby and Libby. Joined by former FBI Special Agent and contributor, Jennifer Coffindaffer, they tackled significant controversies surrounding the investigation and posed a question that has reverberated through time - were crucial investigative errors responsible for delaying justice for the two girls?
For those unfamiliar with the case, Abby Williams and Liberty (Libby) German went missing after an afternoon hike. Their bodies were found near a trail the following day. In the wake of their tragic deaths, the subsequent investigation yielded more questions than answers.
As Brueski noted, "We've been talking about Richard Allen for quite some time, but before his arrest, the FBI had probable cause that it was Ron Logan." This assertion ignited tensions between the FBI and local officials. Coffindaffer detailed this rift, recalling a time when the Bureau had shown interest in Ron Logan as a prime suspect. However, local officials inexplicably seemed to dismiss Logan due to his age, which Coffindaffer found ludicrous. Especially given the compelling evidence against him: "Listen, the crime was committed on his property... [and] he made a fake alibi," she commented.
For many followers of the case, the presence of a video, featuring the voice of a potential suspect, added another layer of intrigue. But, even with this evidence, the identity and role of the man in the video remain disputed. Coffindaffer weighed in, explaining the FBI's voice analysis results, stating, "The FBI will never tell you that voice is this person's voice. What they will tell you is there are characteristics that are the same... in this case, they could not say it wasn't Ron Logan's voice."
But beyond the question of the suspect's identity is a deeper concern - was the investigation itself flawed from the start? Coffindaffer lamented the power struggles evident between various law enforcement agencies, stating that the need for jurisdictional dominance hindered the investigation's progress. "There was such an issue with really who, really an issue of who was going to be the top dog... and that got so much in the way of proper police investigation."
Brueski also brought attention to suspicions of a cover-up, calling out Tony Liggett's handling of the case. His actions, or lack thereof, have led many to believe that to truly bring justice to Abby and Libby, the investigation needs fresh eyes, untainted by prior missteps. Coffindaffer strongly concurred, emphasizing the necessity for a fresh perspective, possibly even suggesting a move outside local law enforcement to get there.
In a poignant end to their discussion, both Brueski and Coffindaffer wondered about the future of the case. With all the challenges and potential misdirections it has faced, will Abby and Libby ever truly receive the justice they deserve?
The episode offers no clear answers but rather leaves listeners with a burning question: In the quest for justice, can we trust the very systems in place to deliver it?
For those unfamiliar with the case, Abby Williams and Liberty (Libby) German went missing after an afternoon hike. Their bodies were found near a trail the following day. In the wake of their tragic deaths, the subsequent investigation yielded more questions than answers.
As Brueski noted, "We've been talking about Richard Allen for quite some time, but before his arrest, the FBI had probable cause that it was Ron Logan." This assertion ignited tensions between the FBI and local officials. Coffindaffer detailed this rift, recalling a time when the Bureau had shown interest in Ron Logan as a prime suspect. However, local officials inexplicably seemed to dismiss Logan due to his age, which Coffindaffer found ludicrous. Especially given the compelling evidence against him: "Listen, the crime was committed on his property... [and] he made a fake alibi," she commented.
For many followers of the case, the presence of a video, featuring the voice of a potential suspect, added another layer of intrigue. But, even with this evidence, the identity and role of the man in the video remain disputed. Coffindaffer weighed in, explaining the FBI's voice analysis results, stating, "The FBI will never tell you that voice is this person's voice. What they will tell you is there are characteristics that are the same... in this case, they could not say it wasn't Ron Logan's voice."
But beyond the question of the suspect's identity is a deeper concern - was the investigation itself flawed from the start? Coffindaffer lamented the power struggles evident between various law enforcement agencies, stating that the need for jurisdictional dominance hindered the investigation's progress. "There was such an issue with really who, really an issue of who was going to be the top dog... and that got so much in the way of proper police investigation."
Brueski also brought attention to suspicions of a cover-up, calling out Tony Liggett's handling of the case. His actions, or lack thereof, have led many to believe that to truly bring justice to Abby and Libby, the investigation needs fresh eyes, untainted by prior missteps. Coffindaffer strongly concurred, emphasizing the necessity for a fresh perspective, possibly even suggesting a move outside local law enforcement to get there.
In a poignant end to their discussion, both Brueski and Coffindaffer wondered about the future of the case. With all the challenges and potential misdirections it has faced, will Abby and Libby ever truly receive the justice they deserve?
The episode offers no clear answers but rather leaves listeners with a burning question: In the quest for justice, can we trust the very systems in place to deliver it?