INTRO: Welcome to the NSPCC Learning Podcast, where we
INTRO: share learning and expertise in child protection from
INTRO: inside and outside of the organisation.
INTRO: We aim to create debate, encourage reflection and
INTRO: share good practice on how we can all work together
INTRO: to keep babies, children and young people safe.
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): Welcome to the NSPCC Learning
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): Podcast. This is the second half
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): of a two part podcast series,
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): recorded in July 2023, looking
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): at the UK government's strategy
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): to reform children's social care
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): in England, 'Stable Homes, Built
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): on Love'.
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): In the previous episode, we
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): interviewed Josh MacAlister, who
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): chaired the Independent Review
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): of Children's Social Care in England.
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): In his foreword to the review's
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): final report, Josh described the
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): need for a care system that will
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): get alongside and strengthen the
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): families and communities that
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): children grow up in.
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): In this episode, a panel of
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): experts from within the NSPCC
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): are going to discuss how the proposals
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): laid out in 'Stable Homes, Built
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): on Love' can achieve this goal.
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): The discussion will focus on the
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): proposed reforms to family
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): support and early help services,
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): what these might look like in practice,
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): and how they might meet the needs
GEORGE LINFIELD (PRODUCER): of children and families.
EAVAN MCKAY: Hi, I'm Eavan Mckay.
EAVAN MCKAY: I'm Senior Policy and Public Affairs Officer
EAVAN MCKAY: here at the NSPCC and my brief focuses on
EAVAN MCKAY: children's social care and child protection.
MATT FORDE: Hi, I'm Matt Forde, I'm a Partnerships and
MATT FORDE: Development Director here at the NSPCC,
MATT FORDE: and I'm responsible for the services that we run
MATT FORDE: in partnership with others, with a big focus on
MATT FORDE: the early years and on the prevention of child
MATT FORDE: sexual abuse.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: Hi, my name's Rachel Holdcroft, I'm the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: Strategic Service Manager at Together for
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: Childhood in Stoke on Trent.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So I oversee the direct casework and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: the development work here in Stoke, all
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: of which focuses on prevention of child
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: sexual abuse.
EAVAN MCKAY: 'Stable Homes, Built on Love' talks about
EAVAN MCKAY: providing families with the right support at
EAVAN MCKAY: the right time and proposes the rollout of
EAVAN MCKAY: new, multi-disciplinary family help teams to
EAVAN MCKAY: provide earlier support to families so they
EAVAN MCKAY: don't reach crisis point.
EAVAN MCKAY: This will involve bringing together targeted
EAVAN MCKAY: early help and child in need into a single
EAVAN MCKAY: family help service.
EAVAN MCKAY: So my question for you both to start is
EAVAN MCKAY: what are your thoughts on these proposals in
EAVAN MCKAY: principle and what do you think is needed to
EAVAN MCKAY: help them work in practice?
MATT FORDE: The principle that what we want to do
MATT FORDE: is get alongside families at a time that
MATT FORDE: helps them is a good one.
MATT FORDE: I think there are some missing parts of the
MATT FORDE: story.
MATT FORDE: The care review, right from the start, the case
MATT FORDE: for change for the care review, said we need to
MATT FORDE: do more to help families and
MATT FORDE: identify the context of poverty and inequality.
MATT FORDE: The review report itself said
MATT FORDE: that we have to address that wider
MATT FORDE: context that drives the demand for children's
MATT FORDE: social care and the stress on families
MATT FORDE: and the impact that has on outcomes for
MATT FORDE: children. And I think the other dimension
MATT FORDE: that isn't present there or isn't visible, is
MATT FORDE: an understanding of the particular importance of
MATT FORDE: early childhood and of getting it
MATT FORDE: so that families with very young children, from
MATT FORDE: pregnancy onwards, get the support that they
MATT FORDE: need to be able to give the children a start in
MATT FORDE: life that makes all the difference.
MATT FORDE: And when you think about children's social care,
MATT FORDE: what heaves into view in your mind is a teenager
MATT FORDE: in a children's home or maybe in a foster care
MATT FORDE: placement. But actually the
MATT FORDE: majority of children in the children's social
MATT FORDE: care system had their first encounters with
MATT FORDE: children's social care before they were five,
MATT FORDE: and a very sizeable chunk of the children
MATT FORDE: actually, in our social care system are under
MATT FORDE: five.
MATT FORDE: And it's a testament to the failure to support
MATT FORDE: those children that we have children spending a
MATT FORDE: whole childhood in a care system rather than in
MATT FORDE: families.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: I agree with and echo, really, what Matt
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: has just said there, I think the other
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: thing for me just to add is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that as a sentence or a principle or as a
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: declaration, I think most people in this
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: profession would support the idea that we
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: bring together early help services for
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: families and offer that support to create
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: stable homes at the earliest point
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: possible.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: One of the concerns that I would have
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: is that in practice we would need
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: skilled, well-resourced practitioners
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: who are able to deliver that type of
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: service. And the other concern is around
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: what early health actually is.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So across the nation there's different
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: thresholds that are applied when
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: determining whether or not a family would
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: qualify for an early help service.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And, I kind of say that in inverted
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: commas. That differentiation and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: thresholds can create national
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: inequality.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And I think what we need to- what needs
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to underpin this principle is universal,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: positive protective messaging.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So tackling a problem before it's
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: happened, so that we're not waiting until
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: families are in crisis or in need of
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: help. We're already giving those positive
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: messages, and that's exactly what Matt's
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: just said. So from pregnancy, right
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: through the early years; informative,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: practical, accessible, positive messaging
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: and help to be shared, you know, is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: shared with families at that point.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: That way, there's trust in services
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that's built so that if they need
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: additional targeted services, that trust,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that relationship and that mutual respect
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: is already embedded in practice.
EAVAN MCKAY: Yeah, I completely agree.
EAVAN MCKAY: And I think that point about what do we mean by
EAVAN MCKAY: early help as well is a really important one.
EAVAN MCKAY: So Matt, you've already talked about babies,
EAVAN MCKAY: infants and the needs of babies and infants,
EAVAN MCKAY: and that was definitely a question I wanted to
EAVAN MCKAY: pick up. The specific needs of babies and
EAVAN MCKAY: infants, as you say, is definitely not a strong
EAVAN MCKAY: focus in 'Stable Homes, Built on Love'.
EAVAN MCKAY: We know babies and infants are the group that
EAVAN MCKAY: are most at risk of abuse and neglect and
EAVAN MCKAY: potentially less child with a social worker.
EAVAN MCKAY: They're also the group who are least seen by
EAVAN MCKAY: agencies and services.
EAVAN MCKAY: What would a future children's social care
EAVAN MCKAY: system that truly meets the needs of babies and
EAVAN MCKAY: infants, what would it look like?
MATT FORDE: Other ways of describing what it what it would
MATT FORDE: look like would be about how it's experienced by
MATT FORDE: families. Hearing the voice of children who are
MATT FORDE: under five; it's also about understanding what
MATT FORDE: what their parents need to be the parents that
MATT FORDE: they want to be, and to understand their
MATT FORDE: experiences in the world and to understand how
MATT FORDE: they may well be experiencing incredible stress.
MATT FORDE: Locked in poverty, families involved in the
MATT FORDE: child protection system. They're in double
MATT FORDE: jeopardy because they have all of
MATT FORDE: the pressures and stresses that come from
MATT FORDE: inadequate income, insecure housing, living in
MATT FORDE: hard-pressed neighbourhoods, and
MATT FORDE: then family crisis that's led them into
MATT FORDE: interaction with children's social care and
MATT FORDE: that experience of working with children's
MATT FORDE: social care can often be further
MATT FORDE: stigmatising and stress-inducing for families.
MATT FORDE: And what the system would look like would be a
MATT FORDE: system that had services that got alongside
MATT FORDE: families, that stood with families, that said,
MATT FORDE: "how can we help?" That said, "where are your
MATT FORDE: strengths and how can we build on them?
MATT FORDE: How can we actually give you practical and
MATT FORDE: material help to alleviate some of this
MATT FORDE: pressure?" And at the same time, let's
MATT FORDE: try and understand where relationships need to
MATT FORDE: be helped and where things might have gone wrong
MATT FORDE: and we can get them back on track.
MATT FORDE: It's not an either or, it's both.
MATT FORDE: And the system would be something that
MATT FORDE: was experienced by families as something that
MATT FORDE: was genuinely there to help.
MATT FORDE: So you wouldn't have to navigate, you know,
MATT FORDE: hostile systems of appointments set in distant
MATT FORDE: places at times it's difficult to get to that
MATT FORDE: when you got there there would be food available
MATT FORDE: so that your child wouldn't be hungry during the
MATT FORDE: appointment and you wouldn't have to ask for it.
MATT FORDE: It would be an expectation that
MATT FORDE: your story wouldn't have to be told over and
MATT FORDE: over again, that you wouldn't have to go back to
MATT FORDE: the beginning ever, that you would...
MATT FORDE: That you would experience workers being alert
MATT FORDE: and oriented to try and understand what
MATT FORDE: your story is, and they would have time
MATT FORDE: to listen to you. So these are all
MATT FORDE: characteristics of a system that would be
MATT FORDE: getting alongside people.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: The question, Eavan, that you posed was
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: around what would a social care system
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: look like? And I think we need to really
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: consider what a social care system is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: before we can purposefully or
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: meaningfully answer that question.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So a social care system is beyond a
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: social worker.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: The social care system for me needs to be
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: all of that child, baby, infant, parent
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: social network, including communities as
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: well as just professionals.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And if we're really going to affect
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: change here, I think it's crucial to
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: bring everybody on that journey with us.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: In Stoke and Together for Childhood we
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: work very much in a community way and we
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: have seen and we have evidenced just how
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: powerful and influential communities are.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: They're part of that child's networks so
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: they're key in providing that advocacy.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: It doesn't all need to fall... The
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: responsibility doesn't fall just to the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: social worker. And I think if we're going
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to move with the times, if you like, we
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: need to think beyond traditional social
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: work models and when we consider
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: advocacy, we consider it as a big
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: picture. So those people in the community
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: will see a different version of the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: parent and a different version of, once
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: the child gets older, than perhaps we do
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: as professionals. And it's only when we
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: tie all of that together that we really
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: get the full picture. And if we need to
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: intervene, offer early help or more
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: than early help support, we can do that
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: most effectively and most safely
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: when we all are together and we're all
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: working towards a common goal which,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: ultimately, is keeping children safe.
MATT FORDE: And, you know, I think it's absolutely critical
MATT FORDE: for babies and infants that they have advocacy,
MATT FORDE: that their voice is heard.
MATT FORDE: And for their voice to be heard, there's no
MATT FORDE: shortcut. You need highly skilled
MATT FORDE: people who are able to understand
MATT FORDE: a baby or a toddler's experience
MATT FORDE: through the way that they communicate and
MATT FORDE: through understanding the quality of
MATT FORDE: their relationships and to understand
MATT FORDE: what has happened in their life; and to be able
MATT FORDE: to communicate for others who are
MATT FORDE: making decisions about these children or who are
MATT FORDE: responsible for care for these children; to be
MATT FORDE: able to communicate those
MATT FORDE: children's needs. That is skilled
MATT FORDE: work. In the NSPCC, we have teams of
MATT FORDE: multi-disciplinary professionals
MATT FORDE: who are able to do that kind of work and we've
MATT FORDE: demonstrated that that can be done.
MATT FORDE: And, you know, a practice example for us is in
MATT FORDE: our infant and family teams where we work with
MATT FORDE: children aged zero to five who have been removed
MATT FORDE: from their parents' care and who live with
MATT FORDE: foster carers.
MATT FORDE: We work with the foster parent and the child to
MATT FORDE: understand how that relationship
MATT FORDE: is going and to understand whether
MATT FORDE: or not it's good enough for that child's needs,
MATT FORDE: given that nearly always they've experienced
MATT FORDE: trauma, abuse, neglect.
MATT FORDE: And in that context of infant trauma,
MATT FORDE: we find that we
MATT FORDE: can we can express that child's
MATT FORDE: needs in their voice
MATT FORDE: in a way that provides a record for them when
MATT FORDE: they get older through a method we call narrative
MATT FORDE: books. So we produce these books which explain:
MATT FORDE: "Hi, I am..." — the name
MATT FORDE: of the child — "I'm living with"
MATT FORDE: — such and such, foster parents — "here's what's
MATT FORDE: happened to me and decisions that have been made
MATT FORDE: about me. Here's how I am." You know,
MATT FORDE: it could be that "I'm someone that doesn't...
MATT FORDE: When I first went to the foster parents, I
MATT FORDE: didn't seek comfort because in my life before,
MATT FORDE: I'd learned not, but know with my foster parents
MATT FORDE: that's getting better." So it's that kind of
MATT FORDE: articulating through an
MATT FORDE: understanding of what children need.
MATT FORDE: A narrative that is telling their story.
MATT FORDE: If there is to be a system of advocacy for
MATT FORDE: children in care, it really is crucial that
MATT FORDE: infants get that kind of access
MATT FORDE: to their voice being heard.
EAVAN MCKAY: We talked a bit about multi-agency working
EAVAN MCKAY: to support children and families. The principle
EAVAN MCKAY: of multi-agency working and the desire to
EAVAN MCKAY: have these multi-disciplinary teams is in the
EAVAN MCKAY: strategy, and that's something that the Government
EAVAN MCKAY: has said that they're committed to.
EAVAN MCKAY: And as well, linking to what you were saying
EAVAN MCKAY: about working with the whole family, the
EAVAN MCKAY: government talk about this idea in the strategy
EAVAN MCKAY: of a family-first approach.
EAVAN MCKAY: So this means that local authorities will
EAVAN MCKAY: actively seek out and work with a child's
EAVAN MCKAY: direct and extended family and friends in
EAVAN MCKAY: considering the best forms of support for the
EAVAN MCKAY: child and their family.
EAVAN MCKAY: And I guess my question is on those two points,
EAVAN MCKAY: on the multi-disciplinary and multi-agency
EAVAN MCKAY: working and on this idea of working with the
EAVAN MCKAY: whole family and a family-first approach.
EAVAN MCKAY: We've talked about the benefits, of which there
EAVAN MCKAY: is the so many and thinking about this future
EAVAN MCKAY: system, I guess what are some of the barriers
EAVAN MCKAY: to making that happen?
EAVAN MCKAY: I'm curious to hear your perspective from
EAVAN MCKAY: a practitioner level.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: What we find in practice, and certainly
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: what I found in my practice, is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that the way the system currently
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: operates can perpetuate
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: or can create conflicting priorities
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: between organisations.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So there would need to be robust
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: working practices that ensure that
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: all of those multi-agencies are working
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: for a common goal without bias or
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: prejudice and without their own priority
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: taking over.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: The fact that the number one priority is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: the children and the family at the heart
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: of this and at the centre of this.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And I think you could speak to any practitioner
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: who has experienced difficulty in driving
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: forward plans because of bureaucracy
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: or because of conflicting priorities or
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: boundaries that their organisation might
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: create. So I think the principle works
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: well, but there needs to be really
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: careful consideration as to how that
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: principle is operationalised because the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: people that are going to be responsible
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: for the success of children coming
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: from safe homes that are built on love
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: and are stable.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: It's the professionals that will need the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: support, they need to be well-trained,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: supported, resourced. Mutual respect
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: between professionals and an
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: understanding that there is that shared
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: accountability. That's the overarching
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: thing for me. That the accountability for
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: the success of the whole plan that is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: underpinning the family needs to be
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: shared across in an equally respectful
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: way, shared across those and throughout
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: the multi-disciplinary.
MATT FORDE: So if I could add to that, you've painted a
MATT FORDE: really clear picture there Rachael of what a
MATT FORDE: functional system should look like.
MATT FORDE: The only thing I'd add to that is
MATT FORDE: what would be the glue that would hold that
MATT FORDE: together? It's not just structural or managerial
MATT FORDE: action that's needed there.
MATT FORDE: It's at the heart of it you need relationships
MATT FORDE: with families; meaningful, supportive
MATT FORDE: relationships. People are
MATT FORDE: human beings and what they need is a human
MATT FORDE: relationship with the professionals, and
MATT FORDE: having at the core a productive caring
MATT FORDE: relationship with the family involved
MATT FORDE: will help you then work with, advocate
MATT FORDE: for, stand beside that family as they navigate
MATT FORDE: what will, no matter what, will be a complex
MATT FORDE: system. And the relationship dimension
MATT FORDE: of it really to me is the sort of 'X factor'
MATT FORDE: that would make it all work.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And I think the start of having a
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: workforce that can build those
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: relationships starts at recruitment and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: really pulling out some of those values,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: behaviours and attitudes.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And if we are genuinely going to work
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: with families in a way that doesn't make
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: them feel shame, then we need to do so
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: with high levels of empathy and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: understanding. There are supplementary
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: courses that people can access.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So, throughout your social work training,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: teacher training, health visitor training,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: there will be modules that encourage the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: workforce to build relationships.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: How you do that sits with you and how you
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: make it better sits at experience.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So you will go out and there will be
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: times where you might work with a family
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: and things haven't gone to plan.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: Coming back, having a strong supportive
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: manager with a work culture that
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: doesn't operate in a blame way.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So we work through things together, talk
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: things out with peers, with mentors,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: with your supervisor. How could you do
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: this better? But then there is also
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: training that can be accessed, such as
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: motivational interview training,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: reflective practice training.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: There's reflective supervision.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So I think it's not a one size fits all.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: I think it starts with recruitment and it
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: starts with really employing people
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: who've got a solid value base that aligns
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to social work. And then working with an
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: open mind with other professionals,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: observing how they interact and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: communicate with families, and really
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: learning back from families.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So if things haven't gone well, if
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: conversations haven't gone well, being
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: open to that feedback from families:
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: "okay, tell me what I could do better
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: next time", and really bringing them into
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that conversation.
EAVAN MCKAY: Yeah, I'm really glad you both
EAVAN MCKAY: brought up that point there about relationships
EAVAN MCKAY: and also the kind of the need to be able to
EAVAN MCKAY: equip social workers to be able to have that
EAVAN MCKAY: space to develop those relationships as well
EAVAN MCKAY: and to make sure they're strong.
EAVAN MCKAY: I guess one thing I'm thinking about is the
EAVAN MCKAY: proposals indicate that in this future system,
EAVAN MCKAY: when these reforms are fully rolled out, that
EAVAN MCKAY: non-social workers, so family health
EAVAN MCKAY: workers working alongside the family help teams
EAVAN MCKAY: — so these multi-disciplinary teams — may
EAVAN MCKAY: become the case holders for non-child
EAVAN MCKAY: protection cases. Are you supportive of this
EAVAN MCKAY: idea in principle and what would need to be in
EAVAN MCKAY: place to make it work in practice as well?
MATT FORDE: I think what's important is what would
MATT FORDE: the skills be of the workers who would be
MATT FORDE: supporting families? So would they have
MATT FORDE: the ability to be able to understand
MATT FORDE: children's needs, especially young children's
MATT FORDE: needs, but children's needs in a developmentally
MATT FORDE: informed way.
MATT FORDE: Would they be able to understand what is
MATT FORDE: important in parent-child relationships and
MATT FORDE: how to assess what is going on.
MATT FORDE: Would they have the ability to form caring
MATT FORDE: relationships within a professional relationship
MATT FORDE: with families, to enable them to navigate the
MATT FORDE: stresses and pressures that they face.
MATT FORDE: The answer for social workers would be yes to
MATT FORDE: most of that, although I do think we could do
MATT FORDE: more to equip social workers with theoretical
MATT FORDE: and practical expertise in child
MATT FORDE: development, parent-child relationships,
MATT FORDE: understanding intergenerational trauma.
MATT FORDE: And I think the focus within children's
MATT FORDE: social work has been dominated by
MATT FORDE: assessment of risk, identification and
MATT FORDE: assessment of risk and management of risk — and
MATT FORDE: that's what dominates.
MATT FORDE: That's a dominant paradigm.
MATT FORDE: The risk paradigm.
MATT FORDE: Really, having a more person-centred approach
MATT FORDE: is something that all professionals maybe need
MATT FORDE: help with recentring their practice.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: I completely agree. I think it comes back
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to the first point we made around the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: principle is fine as long as it's safely
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: delivered.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And that is exactly what Matt's just
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: spoken about there, the training, the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: support, the reflective supervision, but
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: also the oversight.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So I think I'm right in my understanding
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that whilst the case holders could be
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: non-social workers, the oversight would
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: come from a lead professional or somebody
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that was a qualified social worker that really
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: did understand child safeguarding; so
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: could have the safeguarding oversight
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: whilst the specific actions within the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: plan were delivered and coordinated by
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: another professional.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: I think the difficulty again comes back
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to some of the professional boundaries.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So, when we think about how do we form
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: relationships, they don't happen
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: overnight, especially for families who
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: have got issues with trusting
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: professionals because of previous
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: experiences, you know, parents who are
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: maybe care-experienced themselves or have
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: had a difficult relationship with
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: professionals are going to find it very
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: hard to automatically trust somebody,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: whatever their title may be.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: The negative could come from giving the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: responsibility for the coordination of a
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: family help plan or system
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to a professional within an organisation
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that is time limited.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So if we can say to some of the organisations
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that we work alongside, they run 12 or 18
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: week programs, that may not be long
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: enough. And then we're expecting families
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to form new relationships with a new
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: co-ordinator. So there'd need to be some
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: robustness around the lead
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: worker remaining the lead worker and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: organisational time restrictions not
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: playing into that or not becoming a
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: priority. So if it takes six or seven or
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: eight weeks to build that relationship,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that doesn't mean that you've only got
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: six weeks left because that's what we say
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: as an organisation you're entitled to.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: However, I also think the relationship
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: with some professionals outside of social
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: work can be extremely positive.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: I've seen family support workers do
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: exceptional work with children and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: families. I've seen health visitors,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: school link workers really make a
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: difference. And some of that comes
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: because they have that really positive
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: relationship. It's a non-threatening
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: relationship.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: It's not a shameful relationship.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: It's not a relationship that brings any
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: kind of stigma because these are
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: universal services that all families are
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: entitled to that may then become
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: targeted, but it doesn't bring with it an
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: element of threat or an element of shame
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: or an element of stigma.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: It's a more nurturing model.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: The relationship underpins the plan.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: The success of the plan is to do with the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: structure, so it's the wider system and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: how that structure supports the delivery.
MATT FORDE: One of the things that workers need to do to
MATT FORDE: be able to be part of a non-stigmatising
MATT FORDE: conversation is to respect families' rights
MATT FORDE: to say no to elements of things.
MATT FORDE: You've been signposted over here and over there.
MATT FORDE: If that's not going to work, and family says so,
MATT FORDE: can we please listen to that. And
MATT FORDE: similar points about picking up the one time
MATT FORDE: that somebody says something, you have to
MATT FORDE: respond that one time. Particularly when people
MATT FORDE: talk about things that they think are shameful,
MATT FORDE: like not having enough food. Or are
MATT FORDE: really suffering, you know, financial hardship,
MATT FORDE: those sorts of issues that if they're said once,
MATT FORDE: you have to pick them up.
MATT FORDE: And that's really not about the grade of worker
MATT FORDE: is it, it's about how we equip people
MATT FORDE: with an orientation to help and provide
MATT FORDE: the support to them to be the helpers.
MATT FORDE: And also that we continue to learn and lesson
MATT FORDE: from lived experience.
EAVAN MCKAY: Starting with the idea of "what is the
EAVAN MCKAY: experience of the family" leads us also
EAVAN MCKAY: to asking that question of "what's the
EAVAN MCKAY: motivation of this policy?" And it kind of
EAVAN MCKAY: links to your earlier point, Rachel, about
EAVAN MCKAY: who decides who will lead the cases, for
EAVAN MCKAY: example, when it is a family help worker versus
EAVAN MCKAY: when it is a social worker?
EAVAN MCKAY: I think that feels really crucial because
EAVAN MCKAY: it has to be, you know, whilst there can be so
EAVAN MCKAY: many benefits to the possibility of having a
EAVAN MCKAY: wider field of professionals — or
EAVAN MCKAY: non-professionals as well, you talk about that
EAVAN MCKAY: Matt as well as it not being so
EAVAN MCKAY: professionalised but a wider group of people
EAVAN MCKAY: who can work with families — it
EAVAN MCKAY: has to be about if it's right for the family
EAVAN MCKAY: and it's right for the child, rather than it
EAVAN MCKAY: being motivated by anything else.
EAVAN MCKAY: And it feels like, you know, what we can't have
EAVAN MCKAY: is the idea that family health workers could be
EAVAN MCKAY: a silver bullet to saving money because that is
EAVAN MCKAY: not in the interests of children and families
EAVAN MCKAY: at all. So the government plans to introduce
EAVAN MCKAY: a new lead child protection
EAVAN MCKAY: practitioner role. So this practitioner will
EAVAN MCKAY: have a minimum of five years social work
EAVAN MCKAY: experience and will complete advanced
EAVAN MCKAY: specialist child protection training.
EAVAN MCKAY: Our understanding is this new role will be
EAVAN MCKAY: across the system. It won't just be for family
EAVAN MCKAY: help teams. My question is around...
EAVAN MCKAY: What are your thoughts on this new role?
EAVAN MCKAY: Thinking about the benefits to the system it
EAVAN MCKAY: could have, but also any risks you might
EAVAN MCKAY: foresee in terms of the implementation.
MATT FORDE: To me, the crucial issue is what are the
MATT FORDE: advanced skills and knowledge that this person
MATT FORDE: would have. The way that we've structured child
MATT FORDE: protection as a social work-led activity
MATT FORDE: has locked into a professional framework
MATT FORDE: that doesn't really value expertise.
MATT FORDE: That, you know, if you progress as a social
MATT FORDE: worker, you become a manager and stop being
MATT FORDE: involved with families. Whereas in health
MATT FORDE: professions and mental health, for example,
MATT FORDE: psychologists and psychiatrists and
MATT FORDE: psychotherapists progress to become consultants
MATT FORDE: who are at a higher level of skill and
MATT FORDE: expertise, but continue to be in practice with
MATT FORDE: families. I think that is the
MATT FORDE: kind of structure we should have professionally
MATT FORDE: around the social work professionals or child
MATT FORDE: protection professionals who are doing the most
MATT FORDE: complex and challenging work.
MATT FORDE: They should have... They should have a level
MATT FORDE: of skill and expertise that's commensurate with
MATT FORDE: the complexity of children's needs and families'
MATT FORDE: lives.
MATT FORDE: But it's what that is, because my concern
MATT FORDE: would be that it would be a kind of
MATT FORDE: amplification of the risk assessment
MATT FORDE: mode that our system is locked in.
MATT FORDE: And it would really need to be supplemented by
MATT FORDE: skills which understand how it is you help
MATT FORDE: families. I mean, to understand how we negotiate
MATT FORDE: the benefits system; how you improve families'
MATT FORDE: ability to care for themselves and bring in
MATT FORDE: adequate income; how you understand mental
MATT FORDE: health, and what it is that drives
MATT FORDE: the stresses that undermine mental health; to
MATT FORDE: understand intergenerational trauma;
MATT FORDE: parent-child relationships; infant trauma, to
MATT FORDE: understand what it is that pressures on whole
MATT FORDE: families and whole communities.
MATT FORDE: Those are dimensions that are kind of missing
MATT FORDE: from, you know, the fairly arid assessments of
MATT FORDE: risk that result in — I'm oversimplifying —
MATT FORDE: but result in ultimatums
MATT FORDE: to families to change things by a certain time
MATT FORDE: or there will be action, instead of getting
MATT FORDE: alongside.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So, in terms of that lead professional
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: role, I think having a social
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: worker and somebody with that level of
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: safeguarding expertise is crucial
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: in ensuring that all of the — whoever is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: that's leading the plan — and all of the
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: multi agencies that are part of that
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: plan, there does need to be somebody that
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: can always bring this back to "how safe
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: is this child?" and can knowingly, with
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: expertise, be able to answer that
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: question, support the professionals to
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: demonstrate that curiosity when
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: necessary, really challenge professionals
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to keep thinking about safety as well as
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: their own expertise.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So that role is crucial in that space.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And I think whether that's a lead professional
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: or another title, having
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: space or the opportunity to grow and
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: develop professionally for a social
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: worker is really important.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And it might support some of the issues
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: around retaining good staff because you
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: can see a progression opportunity.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: So I do think in terms of continuing
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: to make sure that the child remains safe
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: in the family and that the plan is
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: effective, in terms of meeting the needs,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: but ultimately keeping the child safe; to
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: have that professional, whether it's a
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: lead social worker or a social worker,
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: having oversight of a plan is crucial.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: That's how we keep children safe.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: That's why social workers are here;
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: because we want to keep children safe.
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: And when they're not safe, we want to
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: take action to bring them back to a place
RACHAEL HOLDCROFT: of safety.
INTRO: Thanks for listening to this NSPCC Learning podcast.
INTRO: At the time of recording this episode, content was
INTRO: up-to-date but the world of safeguarding and child
INTRO: protection is ever-changing.
INTRO: So, if you're looking for the most current
INTRO: safeguarding and child protection, training,
INTRO: information or resources, please visit
INTRO: our website for professionals at
INTRO: nspcc.org.uk/learning.
We recommend upgrading to the latest Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
Please check your internet connection and refresh the page. You might also try disabling any ad blockers.
You can visit our support center if you're having problems.