Reesa Trexler and Christy Mirack

In this episode, we discuss two cases. In the first, a teenager is killed in a small city in North Carolina in 1984. For decades, the police had a prime suspect, but are they really the killer?

Then, in 1992, a popular teacher was murdered in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. What shocked the people of Lancaster more than the murder, was the man who was convicted of committed it.